Crouch v Carroll

[Kurt.]

2 big target men types... similar in many ways but so so different too.......which would you have if offered 1 of them ??? explain your decision why....

For me it would be Crouchy..

reason being ...... he is a better technical player who can easily bring others into play but also scores a shed load of goals.

 

[chrissyjack]

Carroll ......Coz he's as good as Big Dunc. Aldo said so

 

[EFCNIK]

Like them both tbh.

 

[BlueLlama]

Crouch because he doesn't beat his Mrs up

 

[toffeejack]

they're both bad tits but i think crouch deserves it, has a really good scoring record for someone of that size and he's score all sorts of goals, carrol's have mainly been one dimensional. crouch also has a great i'national scoring record

 

[dixie7]

carroll becuase I havent seen many strikers do what he did for newcastle. He is only 23 under the right manager and if he plays for the right team he could end up winning them games.

Crouch sort of stuck at that same level and never progressed and he is now 31. usually spends 2-3 seasons at a team and moves on

 

[BlueWeasel]

How old is he under the wrong manager?

 

[Neiler]

Carroll by a mile if you set up your team to play to his strengths hes unplayable.