Ignore the Barry fanboys mate, you're spot on. Our record without Barry is great, even last season when we were in the worst of it McCarthy and Gibson secured wins v Newcastle and QPR. With the ball at his feet he's very decent, no doubt about it, but off the ball he is miles off the pace. Don't care whether he's been best of a bad bunch, we're 12th, no one is 'vital'. Our defensive record is shocking, as is our ability to see out games. We fade hugely. Therefore your prime areas to look in the team are GK, centrebacks and defensive mid. Most people on here seem happy to put the boot in on genuine proven class like Jags and knock Stones, yet will wail hysterically if you even question Barry.
Any other sides in the league playing a 35 year old every game often twice a week? Maybe they're all wrong and Barry is just sensational, or maybe carrying a past it player is a contributing factor to us being 12th.