Brands Transfers Assessment;

[Eggs]

Thought this might be worth it’s own thread & a useful reference to capture Brands dealings in one place.

Ahead of this window, The Echo has analysed his 21 signings and scored them out of 10;

Richarlison 9
Digne 9
Virginia 7
Bernard 6
Mina 7
Gomes 6
Zooma 8
Lossl 4
Delph 4
Gbamin 5
Kean 6
Sidebe 6
Iwobi 5
Branthwaite 7
Nkounkou 6
Allan 8
Rodriguez 8
Doucoure 8
Godfrey 9
Olsen 7
King 5

Always an engaging topic of conversation regarding how we think he’s done.

 

[Death]

Thought this might be worth it’s own thread & a useful reference to capture Brands dealings in one place.

Ahead of this window, The Echo has analysed his 21 signings and scored them out of 10;

Richarlison 9
Digne 9
Virginia 7
Bernard 6
Mina 7
Gomes 6
Zooma 8
Lossl 4
Delph 4
Gbamin 5
Kean 6
Sidebe 6
Iwobi 5
Branthwaite 7
Nkounkou 6
Allan 8
Rodriguez 8
Doucoure 8
Godfrey 9
Olsen 7
King 5

Always an emotive topic of conversation regarding how we all think he’s done.

Lol Iwobi 5.

 

[Tigger]

VERY generous.

 

[Oasis1878]

Some of those are ludicrously high

 

[Marius57]

Lossl was better than King.

 

[Blueclouds]

But some of these are players wanted by managers, we cant judge brands on this process

 

[Jimmyjoe]

Most of those ratings are ridiculous. Way, way too high.

 

[anton66]

Iwobi and Delph -0
Bernard-2

 

[Nymzee]

I think some of them need context. I don’t see how Lossl, a backup keeper on a free, can have such a low score when he wasn’t even brought in to play.

 

[Brett Angell Delight]

There’s a lot to unpack, there.

How is 4 the lowest score? Gomes is nowhere near a 6. Josh King played about 45 seconds cumulatively and cost us a few mil but he’s a 5?

 

[Tramps_mate]

Thought this might be worth it’s own thread & a useful reference to capture Brands dealings in one place.

Ahead of this window, The Echo has analysed his 21 signings and scored them out of 10;

Richarlison 9 7
Digne 9 8
Virginia 7 5
Bernard 6 3
Mina 7 6
Gomes 6 5
Zooma 8 7
Lossl 4 0
Delph 4 2
Gbamin 5 0
Kean 6 5
Sidebe 6 6
Iwobi 5 5
Branthwaite 7 5
Nkounkou 6 5
Allan 8 8
Rodriguez 8 7
Doucoure 8 8
Godfrey 9 9
Olsen 7 7
King 5 2

Always an engaging topic of conversation regarding how we think he’s done.

I think the echo were very generous. Mine I feel are closer. Some not the players fault but...

 

[Noble Savage]

Delph a 4 ? I suppose 2 of those is that he has legs .
He has hardly played , his attitude stinks and he spends most of the match picking bits of toilet paper out of his teeth after the constant bum licking of a team that clearly didn't want him .
He has the same score as Lossl . A competent goalie .

 

[Toast]

Should have their transfer fee and salary next to them.
That would give us a better idea I reckon.

 

[Dixieslaces]

Gbamin!!!! What!!!

How???

Who wrote this?

they need to be removes as a competent sports journo and moved to covering School Nativities!!!

 

[ToffeeTim]

Thought this might be worth it’s own thread & a useful reference to capture Brands dealings in one place.

Ahead of this window, The Echo has analysed his 21 signings and scored them out of 10;

Richarlison 9 8
Digne 9 8
Virginia 7 5
Bernard 6 5
Mina 7 7 - would get an 8 if available more often
Gomes 6 5
Zooma 8 7
Lossl 4 2 (did he actually make an appearance?)
Delph 4 3
Gbamin 5 2 - unfortunate due to injuries
Kean 6 4
Sidebe 6 6 - fair
Iwobi 5 3
Branthwaite 7 6 - still have hopes
Nkounkou 6 5 - still have hopes
Allan 8 6 - would get higher if fit more often
Rodriguez 8 7 (an 8 for performance but a 6 for availability, evening out at a 7)
Doucoure 8 7
Godfrey 9 8 (9 is a bit over the top - he still made some mistakes)
Olsen 7 7 - fair assessment - he did his job last season
King 5 3

Always an engaging topic of conversation regarding how we think he’s done.

I have to say some of those are way higher than I would put. 2 PL goals in 2 years for a 30m pound signing gets a 5/10? King hardly played and didn't have one goal involvement but gets a 5? What do you have to do to get under 5?

Average rating of my scores comes in at a rather disappointing 5.4