Out of our current squad it would have to be:
GK Tim Howard ( Only real option )
RB Seamus Coleman ( Amazing attacking and good speed. He can recover with it as well )
CB Phil Jagielka ( 2nd Best CB at the club )
CB John Heitinga ( Best CB at the club )
LB Leighton Baines ( No competition )
RM Victor Anichabe ( Powerful and direct. Was great before his injury and will be back next season better )
DM Maroane Fellaini ( A lot better than Rodwell currently )
CM Mikel Arteta ( Best creative player at the club )
LM Steven Pienaar ( Amazing winger with no real competition )
AM Diniyar Bilyaletdinov ( Better than Cahill at everything but heading. Even if he hasnt shown his best )
ST Yakubu ( Better goal scorer than Saha and still contributes out of form unlike Saha )
Howard
Coleman Jagielka Heitinga Baines
Fellaini Arteta
Anichabe Bilyaletdinov Pienaar
Yakubu