This season it has to be Coleman, the guy has been formidable in defence and sheer class going forward. Overall, i'd say Zabaleta, i personally think he's so vastly underrated.
It is the first time, i can genuinely say, when a vote has came up that i can genuinely say an Everton (or Cheese on Toast) player is best, and mean it. For Years, Ashley Cole was the best, his performance against us in the cup final was ridiculous! Baines is great, but Coleman has been great this year, and Zabaleta certainly more consistent!