Attacking Analysis at Birmingham

Status
Not open for further replies.

neonleon

Player Valuation: £35m
So with two consecutive clean sheets under our belt its looking like, as we all know, the major problems lie at Everton with scoring. For me scoring is fairly inevitable providing we attack successfully and create chances. I don't believe we've been doing that despite overwhelming possession in the majority of matches we played.

Part of this seems to be a lack of urgency going forward. If you look at Blackpool today against Liverpool, they counter attacked with great speed, from breaking up a play, in three passes they had players running into space behind the defenders. We seem to play a languid keep ball this year, stroking it around horizontally, giving the defences time to regroup and put ten men behind the ball.

We also in finding a space for tim cahill and yakubu, have no-one playing killer balls through the centre. All our attacking intent comes from the wings and most of that in the form of crosses. Lets have a look at the centre first:

arteta.jpg


Arteta has an unearthly ability for a successful pass. He's the gravy the stew is served in. And yet apart from the corners (passes and crosses are one and the same on these things), he didn't muster a single successful forward ball into the box. We look at Arteta as our creative midfielder. He is not doing this either through loss of form or managerial orders. WE NEED BALLS ON THE DECK INTO SPACE FOR YAK AND CAHILL TO RUN ONTO.

fellaini.jpg


Fellaini is less successful at keeping the ball and accurately distributing although in his defence, many balls are played to his head rather than his feet. Note how many attempts he made to slip balls through to players in the box. Only one.

cahill.jpg


Cahill's game is more about running, shooting, getting into scoring positions but this graphic shows how isolated he was. He also gave the ball away to an alarming degree.

So between the three central midfielders (including cahill) we managed just one ball into the box and that was mopped up.

So we are utterly lacking penetration from the centre. Nobody is playing balls into space for yakubu/cahill. We are playing keep ball.

Its a different story on the wings. On the left, Ossie and Baines combined effectively

left.jpg


Baines put eight balls into the box (either passes or crosses, 3 found their target and one was the tim cahill goal)

Osman put six balls into the box (3 found their target). Altogether the left side of midfield put in 14 balls, 6 found their man and one was a goal - not including the o.g which also came from the left)

The contrast between the right side is stark.

rightside.jpg


Coleman managed only three balls into the box. None of which were successful. Neville managed four balls into the box. Again, none of them found their man or they were defended. Neville also managed to misplace 10 passes out of 40. A staggering quarter, 25% of all his passes.

The chalkboards back up my belief that Osman wasn't at fault for losing possession a majority of times. The right side were far worse. The chalkboards don't show it but Coleman spent a great deal of time attempting to dribble down the right side. This gives us another dimension there, but inevitably we gave the ball up numerous times. Neville is a great captain and a natural leader on the field but he has easily become our worst player. Thats even including Distin. We need a better player to go with Coleman - either that's Landon in January (with Coleman reverting to right back) or playing Hibbert or Heitinga at RB instead of Neville.

In short, we need
1 to get Arteta playing balls into space behind defenders - something for yak to run at.
2 Moving the ball forward quickly so teams cant regroup.
3 Getting some penetration through the centre. Especially balls played on the deck rather than high balls.
4 We need our right side to match the productivity of our left side.

Yakubu and Cahill had 5 shots all game. This can mostly be put down to the one dimensional state of the attacking. Stroking the ball around laterally in midfield like a continental team guarding a 2 - 0 scoreline is not a recipe for scoring.
 
Last edited:

Nice write up. But I dont think you will get Yak to run at anything.

i disagree with that. He's lost a step since the injury, but he's still running the channels and moving into space. The service hasn't been there mostly. In the awful newcastle game, he was head and shoulders better than Beckford when he came on for him.

People will always accuse yak of laziness, for me its just his style. If he didn't work hard and train well, there is zero chance Moyes would play him; he's that kind of manager.
 
good work, good post. graphs and chart always help.
i think moyes is having arteta play too deep. with him picking out targets in the box, everything will fall into place. they'll start jamming up the middle and our wingers will then have more room to work and cross. but until mikel either gets in form or readjusts his play, our offense isnt going to change.
imo, of course
 
good work, good post. graphs and chart always help.
i think moyes is having arteta play too deep. with him picking out targets in the box, everything will fall into place. they'll start jamming up the middle and our wingers will then have more room to work and cross. but until mikel either gets in form or readjusts his play, our offense isnt going to change.
imo, of course

yeah he seems like he's playing defensive midfield at the moment and I'd sooner see him a little higher up the field with Fellaini further back. I'd also like to see him try a few riskier balls on the deck down field, defence splitting through balls, that kind of thing.

We need to upgrade and settle our right side, its a major weakness.
 

Its a fantastic tool that website it really is.
Looking at the wings, it just shows how good Baines is. Compare how many short passes are made in their corner flag area compared to the right. We would usually say Pienaar and Baines work well one-twoing to eachother and are our creativity, so would expect a similar graph if Pienaar was playing, but this suggests Osman is equal to it.
Really does show how Mikky is pulling the strings, and I believe he is doing the correct thing, switching the play quickly back and forth across the park. What he needs, and what we don't have starting at the moment, is an attacking minded midfielder with an eye for shooting and slipping in passes to compliment him, a Lampard/Gerrard if you will. Cahill is fantastic, but doesn't have these qualities. Bily does, but I wouldn't pick him over Cahill at this stage.
I read in a magazine over here a quote from Moyes saying that he basically has to adjust the team and formation to fit AROUND Cahill. Was a little taken aback by that, great player that he is, I personally wouldn't be constructing a team around him.
 
Wow - fantastic analysis neonleon. Hard to dispute the facts.

I was interested to compare chalkboards to a game from the spring 2010, but couldn't find immediate chalkboards to look at. Dang. If someone has them from old, could be cool.
 
The issue is "the hole" itself, meaning the area where Timmy plays and Yak starts his runs from - there is no movement of the ball there, maybe because it's such a risky place to attempt a play through. In that sense, i mean someone receiving with a defender at his back and playing in an attacking team player - look at blackpool's second goal for a good example. Timmy should be doing this, but doesnt. Tets in tims position or (god forbid moyes!) billy could do this job. God knows we tried! Baines' playthroughs for the penalty shouts look like this, similarly the run-up to Yak's goalline clearance chance. Both botches attempts at central breakthrough play. Hopefully, we'll get better at it come the RS game.
 
Love the Guardian chalkboard, superb tool, really opens your eyes.

I agree with the rest about seeing Arteta drop deep to pick the ball up from the CB and pass it forward, many RS fans are saying the same about Gerrard, he's playing too deep to make too much of an impact.

The right side does need to get settled also, big time.

Little Ossie and Baines combined really well down the left because we never hoof it over there (usually because it's Pienaar, who is also a midget).
 
Love the Guardian chalkboard, superb tool, really opens your eyes.

I agree with the rest about seeing Arteta drop deep to pick the ball up from the CB and pass it forward, many RS fans are saying the same about Gerrard, he's playing too deep to make too much of an impact.

The right side does need to get settled also, big time.

Little Ossie and Baines combined really well down the left because we never hoof it over there (usually because it's Pienaar, who is also a midget).

Its also the speed of the attack through the middle. We are taking far too long to pass forward. This is one of the reasons we have so much possession and are defensively strong but it also means we never catch teams defensively off balance, with all this slow approach play.

What these chalkboards do show, is our attack is completely one dimensional at the moment. All down the left. Stop Baines and whoever is playing in front of him and you've pretty much stopped Everton.

If we can get Fellaini playing deeper and push Arteta up, ask him to take some risks with forward balls played mostly on the ground to either the feet of yakubu or better still space in front of him, we will at least keep defenders on their toes and get some penetration through the middle - even if its at the risk of losing some possession in the game.

What also is illustrated here, is the importance of pace particularly on the wings. Someone with zip down that right wing with coleman behind him could make all the difference. Again though its a balancing act. Coleman looks liable defensively as a player as most attacking full backs are.
 

Its also the speed of the attack through the middle. We are taking far too long to pass forward. This is one of the reasons we have so much possession and are defensively strong but it also means we never catch teams defensively off balance, with all this slow approach play.

What these chalkboards do show, is our attack is completely one dimensional at the moment. All down the left. Stop Baines and whoever is playing in front of him and you've pretty much stopped Everton.

If we can get Fellaini playing deeper and push Arteta up, ask him to take some risks with forward balls played mostly on the ground to either the feet of yakubu or better still space in front of him, we will at least keep defenders on their toes and get some penetration through the middle - even if its at the risk of losing some possession in the game.

What also is illustrated here, is the importance of pace particularly on the wings. Someone with zip down that right wing with coleman behind him could make all the difference. Again though its a balancing act. Coleman looks liable defensively as a player as most attacking full backs are.

Hopefully time will help this..

Agree about needing something extra on the right wing, that's why everyone was praying to see Donovan come back asap
 
Hopefully time will help this..

Agree about needing something extra on the right wing, that's why everyone was praying to see Donovan come back asap

yeah, as we all thought, he's probably a shoe in for January. It'd be nice to have a loan to the end of the season though, a couple of months dont cut it. His pace lifts the burden off the rest of the team. If sides have to worry about him down the right, the left gets more space to play. If defenders have to worry about through balls from the middle, then both wings prosper.

United show the best attacking strategies - they can usually score via the middle, crosses from the wing, long balls over the top and by passing it around waiting for a weak spot. Its having all these dimensions in attack that make them a strong offensive unit. Chelsea can do it also.

One thing I would note is the quality of crosses we've been putting in. Disappointing really. Something that needs to improve. We saw how united hurt us with those low lazer guided crosses.
 
So with two consecutive clean sheets under our belt its looking like, as we all know, the major problems lie at Everton with scoring. For me scoring is fairly inevitable providing we attack successfully and create chances. I don't believe we've been doing that despite overwhelming possession in the majority of matches we played.

One thing I noticed watching and on EvertonTV

Any time we went on the attack, 4 Everton pink shirts were in the box (felli, Cahill, Yak and the winger from the other side the cross was coming in) stretching their back line. Along with Arteta following up.



Every attack and we went 4-2-4... defending 4-1-3-1


If that's aggressive and not negative - Moyes haters - then I don't know what is.

Blues piling into the box!
 
Last edited:
Oh and Moyes distinctly shouting "follow Mikel, go with him Mikel" on the side in a counter...

So felli stayed back and arteta went forward. as a 6 countering (Yak, Cahill, Baines, Osman and Coleman with Mikel)


Much of our midfield problems have been Felli and Arteta learning to play together first few games. Am convinced. That and the right side lack of pace - see Leon's post - I agree.

But it's coming. Balance I mean. And Yak's getting sharper too.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top