PeregrineT
Player Valuation: £40m
I thought it was pretty clear.
But I loathe Keane enough to pretend the other 6 players giving the ball away was all his fault.
But I loathe Keane enough to pretend the other 6 players giving the ball away was all his fault.
Was much better than Tarkowski for much of last season as well.
Not been a fan of his for a long time but credit when it's due.
Nah we all want Everton to win but I think it's fair to say that certain players are targeted far more than others and some fans seem to take delight in criticising them to the point where you have to assume they actually want them to do something that allows them to do it. I mentioned the other day that other players making errors often gets laid at Keane's door now, because there's not been enough to criticise him for individually so you have to somehow create an issue that he can indirectly be blamed for.
toffee82
Player Valuation: £30m
Another game or two and we'll be sat on the toilet with torrential diarrhea wondering why we thought it was ok to eat at Spices of Kashmir again
He’s been brilliant but all his mistakes lead to goals?
I think he’s bang average but is doing ok at the minute, he needs to be replaced as soon as Branthwaite is back fit. If he plays for much longer he will make some of those mistakes you mention, which will no doubt cost us points.
Can’t fault his attitude, he’s just a very limited footballer.
joebocop
Player Valuation: £8m
His general performances have not always been brilliant. He's quite often a liability who makes those around him worse. He is turned easily and not overly good at defending when a player attacks him one on one. His reading of the game is below average too. He's alright at dealing with high balls I guess.
He had a brief purple patch under ancelotti and has been better under Moyes. He generally looks a better player when next to branthwaite too. But that's the case with tarkowski too.
Hinchcliffe's Corner
Player Valuation: £50m
Oh well, that's not me. Sounds like pretty weird behaviour. I couldn't be happier seeing Keane play well despite not wanting him here.
Marcus Kendall
Player Valuation: £10m
Why do you loathe him? He's a brilliant team member who's actually not about himself but the team in general. He's another player who gets pelters on here who when he does well I always smile for him
ToffeeScot
Player Valuation: £20m
Part of a defence that has conceded one goal in three games and that was due to a rancid penalty call.
carolinablue232
Player Valuation: £70m
But literally everyone is happy Keane hasn’t messed up yet…Has anyone suggested otherwise?
Marius57
Player Valuation: £60m
Been fine this season so far, as expected of a 4th choice CB. Couple of mistakes yesterday (one I specifically remember when he lost the ball just in their half and they broke but garner got back).
2 clean sheets in 3 games after all the hysteria that he may have to play a few games.
Not his biggest fan but could see the reasoning for keeping him and he has been solid enough. He knows, as we all do, that upon signing a RB or Branthwaite returning that he is out of the team.
2 clean sheets in 3 games after all the hysteria that he may have to play a few games.
Not his biggest fan but could see the reasoning for keeping him and he has been solid enough. He knows, as we all do, that upon signing a RB or Branthwaite returning that he is out of the team.
And it only being one was also due to some woeful finishing, woodwork, a penalty save and some other excellent goalkeeping.
I wouldn't use that stat as evidence that all is OK at the back. We've got away with quite a bit.
Welcome
Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.
Shop
