It’s not Moyes individually presenting the targets it’s a recruitment committee that he is part of. So I don’t see how you can point the finger at him while also saying he hasn’t been fully behind the signings of Aznou, Alcaraz and Barry.
On Conceição, at one stage Juventus fans genuinely thought he wasn’t staying, so if Everton hadn’t tested the waters it would almost have been a missed opportunity. That’s not unrealistic, it’s just exploring a potential opening.
As for Hammond, his role is to negotiate and structure deals. Most industries have someone in that type of position. We don’t have a Director of Football, so his appointment seems logical to me.
I think Juventus were always signing Conceicao. They werent getting a better player for €30mil and 3 months ago i believe it was in the media that they were in talks to proceed.
This recruitment committee is Hammond, Kinnear and Moyes.
Hammond seemingly fails to do the deals
Moyes fails to provide realistic targets
Kinnear fails to sign off the funds
Clearly Moyes works with the scouts, his contacts and suchlike and proposes the players to the other 2.
So far its been a failure and for months some of us have been saying:
1: Not to have Moyes in control of recruitment
2: To keep Thelwell
3: Why is Hammond joining
Id love to have been wrong but the window has been an utter shambles.
This reminds be of the famous Koeman window.
It’s Zat trying to be Dave-lite with a weird fixation on blaming Moyes for everything
You seem to be obsessed with other people. Perhaps try to read a book or take a course.
All of this can’t be blamed on Moyes. Sure, he may say certain players he’d prefer based on what he’s seen or heard on his own or that’s been presented to him. But he’s a manager, not a scout. He can’t possibly be aware of the hundreds upon hundreds of available options across all leagues he could choose from. Its probably a combination of players he’s worked with in the past, players whose talents has risen to his level to be heard, and what his team is telling him based on what they know Moyes prefers and is looking for. Just not fair to say it’s a one man show. It can’t possibly be.
We know there are 3 people in the committee. Him, Hammond and Kinnear.
How did managers sign players for many years? They work with scouting teams, as Thelwell will have also done.
Was it moyes fault about fofana then whole tranfer management team is to blame
I actually think that was a brilliant target and may still be achievable.
But we were only ever going to get him for a big fee and big wages.
This would be a major coup but its one that we'd have had a chance with.