Confirmed Signing Tyler Dibling

[Nymzee]

My question would be is he at the level right now, that if he came in, Moyes would go bang you're our starting RW over McNeil this season starting at Leeds? I'm not so sure he'd do it.

 

[Noisy noise annoys]

I think we prioritised one winger of the best quality available we could attract mate, be it either side with the idea that Ndiaye is capable of playing both.

Still seems to lack structure - there’s not a hope in hell klopp does this

 

[Noisy noise annoys]

Yup. But suppose 1 season of Branthwaite and we wanted £70million (I know other factors).

If he’s as good as they think, we are a good move for him. He’d be stupid to crave CL and sit on a bench for 2 seasons. And if he came here he’d immediately be our best right back.

There’s a LOT of variables there

 

[bluestevon]

The amount we've bid, plus the timing, plus Paul Joyce reporting it and calling us Ev, suggests to me: Phantom Bid - i.e., the club making it look like "see, we tried".

It's right out the William Kenwright wheelhouse this one.

Disagree, failed public bids now after Moyes stuff to the press lately would be disastrous PR.

 

[efcste97]

The amount we've bid, plus the timing, plus Paul Joyce reporting it and calling us Ev, suggests to me: Phantom Bid - i.e., the club making it look like "see, we tried".

It's right out the William Kenwright wheelhouse this one.

Welcome home Jack Harrison

 

[hallamblue]

He has potential but is nowhere near the finished product. Anything over £15 million is a risk.

 

[Bebeto]

Honestly what is the point...is this some kind of tactic to show the fans they are actually looking to get good players? If it is, it is backfiring big time. There is no way they will sell for that price, probably not even for double the money. Everybody knows that

 

[pfim]

My question would be is he at the level right now, that if he came in, Moyes would go bang you're our starting RW over McNeil this season starting at Leeds? I'm not so sure he'd do it.

No, nor should he.

 

[Kevsleftpeg]

Itis the lack of structure, cannot sign a certain payer so we change our entire MO for next season squad shape????

I think we should by the best players we can and build the team and tactics accordingly. Buying the best left winger available to us and moving NDiaye to the right might be a better combination than buying the best right winger available and keeping NDiaye in the left. There’s no need for us to be rigid in how we play.

 

[Loadsofchemistry]

And what was the conclusion?

Was still going on.

 

[jimmythenut]

He has potential but is nowhere near the finished product. Anything over £15 million is a risk.

I agree, but it's about f-time we took some risks.

 

[Kevsleftpeg]

We can't be that desperate can we ? He's an exciting young player, but I don't see anything in his playing history or his highlights video to justify a price tag much over £15 to £20m.

How much would we sell Harrison Armstrong for?

 

[Saint Domingo]

I’ve never understood rejected bids. The clubs talk, surely they know the price. Never understood the point of putting a low first offer in. Negotiate in private by all means but surely the end of the negotiation when you’ve reached agreement is when a bid goes in?

 

[leslad]

Disagree, failed public bids now after Moyes stuff to the press lately would be disastrous PR.

You are more optimistic than me and I commend that.

 

[Marcus Kendall]

My question would be is he at the level right now, that if he came in, Moyes would go bang you're our starting RW over McNeil this season starting at Leeds? I'm not so sure he'd do it.

He'd start McNeil just like he'll start Beto ahead of Barry. Remember he didn't play Baines at first preferring an out of position Lescott instead