Summer Transfer Window 2025 Thread


Thing is though, that won't make any difference to what the players are actually worth it will it? No football club is sitting there using the Echo to value potential signings, so whether they say it's a fair price or not makes absolutely no difference to anything.

Well it does and it doesnt.

It doesnt make vauations change but it changes the viewed valuation of a player in the eyes of the world if you have media constantly saying one thing about someone.

You only have to look at the pressure we were under last season to sell branthwaite. At the start of the transfer window everyone was saying we wanted £70m minimum. Then over the course of the summer with the media campaign of us to sell him the wider world decided that £40-50m is what we should be happy with and even some of our owe fans started believing it.

It can work the other way as well as were seeing with Elliott. Hes never worth 40m but Liverpool will get it and the media spin will help that happen.
 

IMG_0713.webp
 

Well it does and it doesnt.

It doesnt make vauations change but it changes the viewed valuation of a player in the eyes of the world if you have media constantly saying one thing about someone.

You only have to look at the pressure we were under last season to sell branthwaite. At the start of the transfer window everyone was saying we wanted £70m minimum. Then over the course of the summer with the media campaign of us to sell him the wider world decided that £40-50m is what we should be happy with and even some of our owe fans started believing it.

It can work the other way as well as were seeing with Elliott. Hes never worth 40m but Liverpool will get it and the media spin will help that happen.
I think people hugely overplay the media's role in that type of thing to be honest, that's just not how the real world works. I also think if we had a 22 year old who'd already had a season where they got 18 goal involvements at the top level and had been player of the tournament in a major youth tournament we'd probably think £40m was a fair price, but there we are.
 
Always classed Elliot as a very ordinary player, bit part player for years, runs around a lot, average pace and pops up with thd odd goal. All of a sudden he's for sale, Liverpool need funds for their World record spending spree. Elliot scores goals galore in the U21 tournament, looks the part, he is an average player like, that is liverpool's luck, when it's time to sell, Elliot somehow comes alive and scores goals..for the U21 team. Suddenly he's a £40m pound player, you could not make it up, I hope to the blue Hell we don't buy him.
Elliot finished the final with cramp and an ice block on his knee, they can't get the "105 million" worth of players who flopped against championship relegated Plymouth Argyle out of the door quick enough. Put that in the red echo for once.

There is only one Harvey and his other name is Colin.
💙
 
I'd say for those 3 (Elliott just got player of the tournament, which Gordon got previously and he got bought before that for £40)
Nunez cost them £80m, they will want to recoup a good wedge of that
Chiesa, I'm not sure on, obviously worth more talent wise, but fitness is terrible

Gordon wasnt worth 45m when we sold him. Peoe were happy tosell him for 30m in the summer transfer window.

That was just a perfect storm of Newcastle having more money then sense and being desperate to sign him.

Liverpool might want to recoup a good fee for Nunez but hes completely flopped. 5 goals in the league last season, supposed to be their main striker and in a season they won the league. No ones buying him for 50m
 

I think people hugely overplay the media's role in that type of thing to be honest, that's just not how the real world works. I also think if we had a 22 year old who'd already had a season where they got 18 goal involvements at the top level and had been player of the tournament in a major youth tournament we'd probably think £40m was a fair price, but there we are.

He got 9 goal involvements for liverpool last season.

Dont include goals and assists in the under 21s, means nothing.

Ndiaye got 10 goals last season how much is he worth?
 
The media don’t sell players and clubs don’t value their players based on a newspaper article.

Mbuemo would have been sold for £35 million about 3 weeks ago otherwise. Branthwaite would have been sold for the same.
 
He got 9 goal involvements for liverpool last season.

Dont include goals and assists in the under 21s, means nothing.

Ndiaye got 10 goals last season how much is he worth?
18 the season before. I'm not advocating us signing him or saying he's the greatest player in the world, just that if we're honest we would think he was worth that if he played for us and had those sort of stats. I don't see the point in pretending otherwise really.
 

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top