catcherintherye
Player Valuation: £80m
There’s a bit of that yeah but there’s also what I feel is unecessary criticism of us in comparison to similar clubs of our standing for no other reason than Liverpool don’t like us and therefore their media acolytes set an agenda. Pickford is a prime case, its fine for us to all hate him as he’s our keeper, but in the 17/18 season he’d be decent for us, coming off the back of decent form for Sunderland. Even before he went to the World Cup there was some negative press on him because the media wanted Butland Heaton or Pope to go (quite how being backup at Burnley or relegated with Stoke puts you ahead of being Everton’s number one.). During the World Cup he got panned for the goal against Belgium (might not even be his fault) before eventually getting some decent press for good performances against Columbia and especially Sweden. After the World Cup though it’s like the media couldn’t wait for him to fail, and of course his error against Origi was like they’d died and gone to heaven. Every slight error he makes now has them questioning whether he should be England number one. That’s fine but it’s the glee they do it with. Looking across the league there’s keepers with far better reputations making way more errors than him (e.g Lloris). Yet they’re barely being mentioned. Same with bad tackles, ive never heard one mentioned as much as Pickford’s (and Pickfords was accidental!).
I’m all for getting bad coverage when we deserve it but last time I looked we were having a decent season still in the hunt for Europe and the FA cup whilst other teams threw the domestic trophies. There’s always a feeling though that the media would enjoy another implosion from us. Whereas the likes of Leicester, Villa, West Ham, you don’t see anywhere near the same level of mockery and criticism of the club or individual players.
I've said it loads of times with Pickford, that he wasn't my 1st choice and I've never been sold on him. I also think there was a window where he was criticised by Everton fans before the media piped in. That's not the issue now. I understand for some Evertonians he won't be forgiven for what happened at Anfield, and that he backed it up with Newcastle away (in a lot of ways a much worse performance). However some of the criticism about him, is very tainted by this.
Nick Pope made a couple of howlers for Burnley v City and they are not mentioned. Same with Henderson V Liverpool. The two goals he conceeds are easy saves. One goes through him, and one of them is a poor dink finish that he should stand up for.
I've got no skin in the game with Pickford. But he is rightly number 1. He was England man of the tournament in the most successful campaign England have had in the last 30 years. He has earned at least the next 2 tournaments as England number , and thankfully Southgate does seem to grasp this.
If there was a prime David Seaman about, then maybe you consider his position. But there really isn't.









