2018/19 Marco Silva - New Poll Added

Grade Marco Silva's 2018/19 Season

  • A

  • B

  • C

  • D

  • E

  • F


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
No, I`m merely stating that the season isn`t finished, so I have no idea what position we will finish as I don`t possess a third eye like some on here.

There’s a trend you can see. 30 games 37 points. Unless you believe he can win 8 in a row.
 

The only argument to keep him is based on people not wanting to be perceived as a "sacking club" and blind faith he can turn it around despite the evidence shown this season that he doesn't have a clue.

He's done nothing positive since we lost the Anfield Derby. His tactics do not impress me. The players and results have not improved.

Boot him out the door at season's end because we've seen all he has to give.

I'd rather take a chance on someone new than persist with the devil we know.
 
I will believe the table at the end of the season, anything else is just conjecture and knee jerking.

At this stage of the season, there`s always weird results.

Everton are out of the cup and can’t get 7th which should be the owner’s aim at the start of season.

When the team gets something like 11th in May you would say that is fine it’s a transition season.
 
Everton are out of the cup and can’t get 7th which should be the owner’s aim at the start of season.

When the team gets something like 11th in May you would say that is fine it’s a transition season.
m8 he's literally saying he's just gonna wait till the end of the season before giving his opinion, whats hard to understand lol
 

m8 he's literally saying he's just gonna wait till the end of the season before giving his opinion, whats hard to understand lol

Which is fine.

I was just saying the 30 games were the forecast of the final league position which is likely to be 11th-15th.
 
The only argument to keep him is based on people not wanting to be perceived as a "sacking club" and blind faith he can turn it around despite the evidence shown this season that he doesn't have a clue.

He's done nothing positive since we lost the Anfield Derby. His tactics do not impress me. The players and results have not improved.

Boot him out the door at season's end because we've seen all he has to give.

I'd rather take a chance on someone new than persist with the devil we know.

I completely get this view point and if he got the boot in the Summer it wouldn`t surprise me.

However,I feel that due to the mess that Walsh / Koeman left behind, him and Brands together need one more window to get shut of as many of the duds as possible and also to replace them with better more productive players ( hopefully ).

We would know pretty early into the season if they`ve got it right.

Plus, you would hope that if this the case, that Brands has a ready made replacement lined up in the background, rather than a turkey like Allardyce.

I suspect we will know pretty soon after the season finishes which way we are going to go.
 

I completely get this view point and if he got the boot in the Summer it wouldn`t surprise me.

However,I feel that due to the mess that Walsh / Koeman left behind, him and Brands together need one more window to get shut of as many of the duds as possible and also to replace them with better more productive players ( hopefully ).

We would know pretty early into the season if they`ve got it right.

Plus, you would hope that if this the case, that Brands has a ready made replacement lined up in the background, rather than a turkey like Allardyce.

I suspect we will know pretty soon after the season finishes which way we are going to go.


Nope, sorry but I'm not having him escaping any responsibility for this season for whoever was here before him.

Sod that.

He spent money and got some of his own players in.

We have seen no return on that investment and no progress.

If we could achieve what we did last year before that investment and not improve on that after spending money and bringing in half a starting 11 then that's all that needs to be said.


Just like Allardyce and Koeman a second year has to be earned based on the performance in the first and on that basis it's a taxi for Marco.

The minimum expectation has to be improvement on the year before. Anything else is us regressing closer and closer to doing a Villa.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top