2017/18 Kieran Dowell

Status
Not open for further replies.

Erm yes, I said the thing he needs is regular game time, im confused as to what point your attempting to make, unless you suddenly think the "Chumpionship" is a great league?
Are you saying it's pointless because he didn't start the game tonight but it would be fine if he did start all the time?

Just trying to clarify.
 
Just to keep the discussion fair and balanced...the kid comes off the bench and dominates apparently. He's trained with them for about 2 seconds.

How does this prove he's not good enough for our first team again?

Honestly there's no winning this argument on either side at this point. If he goes out and bosses the championship one side will say "see it's been great for him to get regular games and play against men". Those of us who are right on the other hand will say "he should have been boss for us this year, considering we can't break down teams because we're small and slow and we need a bit of magic in the team".
 
Just to keep the discussion fair and balanced...the kid comes off the bench and dominates apparently. He's trained with them for about 2 seconds.

How does this prove he's not good enough for our first team again?

Honestly there's no winning this argument on either side at this point. If he goes out and bosses the championship one side will say "see it's been great for him to get regular games and play against men". Those of us who are right on the other hand will say "he should have been boss for us this year, considering we can't break down teams because we're small and slow and we need a bit of magic in the team".

If Sigurdsson is deffo coming he'd have gotten next to no game time - outside of cup games and sub appearances.
 

Just to keep the discussion fair and balanced...the kid comes off the bench and dominates apparently. He's trained with them for about 2 seconds.

How does this prove he's not good enough for our first team again?

Honestly there's no winning this argument on either side at this point. If he goes out and bosses the championship one side will say "see it's been great for him to get regular games and play against men". Those of us who are right on the other hand will say "he should have been boss for us this year, considering we can't break down teams because we're small and slow and we need a bit of magic in the team".
One of the worst decisions in recent memory this one. Everyone had him down for the first team but he's judged by probably the only other person who thinks the opposite as being not ready.

It's almost as if it were done in spite.
 
Just to keep the discussion fair and balanced...the kid comes off the bench and dominates apparently. He's trained with them for about 2 seconds.

How does this prove he's not good enough for our first team again?

Honestly there's no winning this argument on either side at this point. If he goes out and bosses the championship one side will say "see it's been great for him to get regular games and play against men". Those of us who are right on the other hand will say "he should have been boss for us this year, considering we can't break down teams because we're small and slow and we need a bit of magic in the team".

How does being great against Millwall prove he's ready for starting most weeks in the first team.

I'm all for this loan, great to see him playing and great to see him do well. Hopefully this season is the making of him.
 
One of the worst decisions in recent memory this one. Everyone had him down for the first team but he's judged by probably the only other person who thinks the opposite as being not ready.

It's almost as if it were done in spite.

lol one of the worst decisions in recent memory lol

I've watched him a good few times the last 3/4 years and the kid has got quality but he can massively let games just drift him by. Going out on loan is fantastic for him AND for us because he's getting real experience and all being well he will come back a better player.
 
Wow. What a terrible take. He'll get a TON of game time in the Championship and get better as a player. That's why he's there. He's not as good as Rooney, Klaseen, Siggy (when he's here), or whoever else we can put in his spot.

Sooooo...would you rather have him sit on the bench most of the year with a couple appearance or go to Forrest and get better to the point where we could slot him in? Duh. No brainer, great move.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Top