...yep, I feel a bit similar. I know Keane's 'heading' stats are good but you suggest Gibson comes out better on stats front. Also, I have the vision of Lukaku spinning Keane easily and scoring in the recent game at Goodison. I won't be overly bothered if Keane arrives or not but if he's the player RK wants then that's the important point.
Lukaku has spun many good defenders.