Luke Garbutt

Try to keep him, or let him leave ?


  • Total voters
    308
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Good player Bertrand but not 'top notch'. Shaw is an incredible prospect who will be in the squads just because he's at UTD. Other than Cresswell i think (and may be wrong) theres not many more names out there so Garbutt 'may'be in a shortlist of four for the two slots.

He has a very strong chance i think if he stays with us and learns from baines.


Luke Shaw & Ryan Bertrand.
 

Off topic
Good player Bertrand but not 'top notch'. Shaw is an incredible prospect who will be in the squads just because he's at UTD. Other than Cresswell i think (and may be wrong) theres not many more names out there so Garbutt 'may'be in a shortlist of four for the two slots.

He has a very strong chance i think if he stays with us and learns from baines.
image.webp
 
This thread is (supposed to be) about Luke Garbutt.

Please all, reign in the silliness in the Everton forum.
 

From what I've seen this season and comparing it to the 'he's going to be ace' forecasts we have heard that many times already with many other previous prospects, and also then with the increase he is now demanding, then I would let him go.

His corners and crossing in some of the Europa League games were poor to say the least and his positioning was suspect a few times. I know he's young but there's too much what ifs with this guy and even if he does stay, whats the chances he won't start stamping his feet again in a year or two!

We don't need players who aren't even first team regulars (especially out of contract ones) demanding this that and the other after the season we have had.
 

We know Barkley is on 65K.

Is he really? How can he possibly be one of our top earners? He hasn't done much to deserve that, especially at only 21 years old.

To be honest, I don't think I've ever personally known a 21 year old kid who could command a salary of 65k a year, let alone 65k a week!
 
Is he really? How can he possibly be one of our top earners? He hasn't done much to deserve that, especially at only 21 years old.

To be honest, I don't think I've ever personally known a 21 year old kid who could command a salary of 65k a year, let alone 65k a week!

New TV deal means PL wages will be increasing for players at all clubs across the board.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top