The End of Season Martinez Poll

Martinez In or Out ?

  • Out Now - Seen enough already thanks

    Votes: 127 19.8%

  • In till at least Christmas - Give him some time to show he's turning it round

    Votes: 288 44.8%

  • Give him at least the full season 2015/16

    Votes: 153 23.8%

  • He should be allowed to see his contract out

    Votes: 39 6.1%

  • I just don't know, on toast

    Votes: 36 5.6%
  • Total voters
    643
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Christiffa25 said:
I'm sure your right cheese. It doesn't change the fact though that is what this club needs. A big name manager.

There's players young and old in this squad that need that calibre of managed to progress. As you said getting such a manager is near on impossible.

Unfortunately players like barkley, stones, McCarthy, even older players like Coleman, Baines, jags are unlikely to win anything or reach their full potential remaining at everton playing under an average manager.
Click to expand...

Martinez is a bigger name manager than Brendan Rodgers.

Martinez has actually won something.

@davek
 

bizzaro said:
Martinez is a bigger name manager than Brendan Rodgers.

Martinez has actually won something.

@davek
Click to expand...

I bet if you asked Wigan would they rather have an FA cup or be in the Premiership they would choose the league every time.

No team has ever won the FA Cup and gone down from the top tier in the same season. Our current manager managed that fantastic feat and just for ****s and giggles brought the playing staff and a handful of players with him. To a club aiming for Champions league - that is beyond stupid.
 
applecrumble said:
I bet if you asked Wigan would they rather have an FA cup or be in the Premiership they would choose the league every time.

No team has ever won the FA Cup and gone down from the top tier in the same season. Our current manager managed that fantastic feat and just for ****s and giggles brought the playing staff and a handful of players with him. To a club aiming for Champions league - that is beyond stupid.
Click to expand...

We're just talking about 'big name' or not.

Martinez is a big name in comparison to Rodgers. He's won something.
 

applecrumble said:
Technically so has Rodgers - he won the playoff final and promotion to Premiership + his management record is better. So no Martinez is not a big name compared to Rodgers.

http://www.premierleague.com/en-gb/clubs/managers/profile.overview.html/brendan-rodgers
http://www.premierleague.com/en-gb/clubs/managers/profile.overview.html/roberto-martinez
Click to expand...

Talk about scraping the barrel.

I meant - won something - MEANINGFUL like a major trophy.

LOL

Plus Rodgers just got bummed 6-1 by Stoke. LOL better record my arse

@davek
 
bizzaro said:
Talk about scraping the barrel.

I meant - won something - MEANINGFUL like a major trophy.

LOL

Plus Rodgers just got bummed 6-1 by Stoke. LOL better record my arse

@davek
Click to expand...

Your arse indeed - 31% win rate for Martinez compared to 47% win rate for Rodgers (who has played almost twice as many games)
 
applecrumble said:
I bet if you asked Wigan would they rather have an FA cup or be in the Premiership they would choose the league every time.

No team has ever won the FA Cup and gone down from the top tier in the same season. Our current manager managed that fantastic feat and just for ****s and giggles brought the playing staff and a handful of players with him. To a club aiming for Champions league - that is beyond stupid.
Click to expand...
Wrong. The FA Cup program last night featured Wigan and Martinez said the fans stated they wanted the cup over safety. 'A cup title lasts forever, but we can bounce back from relegation or be relegated in the future' was the jist they were getting at.
 

davek said:
Dont know mate. I know loads of registered users lurk without posting...no doubt mostly bona fide Evertonians too. It'd be nice to read their views.
Click to expand...

Your Sarcasm knows no bounds Da-Veck ;)
 
Both Martinez and Rogers are both average managers who have done nothing in the big scale of things.

One FA cup win means nothing to me tbh. It's nice don't get me wrong but building what moyes did over 10yrs is a better feat IMO than the one FA cup fluke of martinez.

But hey ho everyone has there own opinions, that's what makes forums such a wonderful place!
 
I can't vote in this poll - my view is he gets around 8 games. If we're bottom half come October he should be bulleted.
 
davek said:
75% say "Roberto IN".

As it should be.

Those who voted Martinez out...or put another way: 'the losers':

...funny that, never seen most of those posting on here. :coffee:

However, @the esk - tut tut tut!!!
Click to expand...

The ones who voted "stay til Xmas" are basically saying he's on his last chance, which is more leaning towards "out" than "in" as it stands
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top