Naismith? Thoughts?

[tim cahill]

http://www.scotzine.com/2012/09/naismith-could-be-in-trouble-after-he-hits-out-at-serb/?

It's a f***ing elbow!

Looks like his forearm to me.

 

[tim-cahill-legend]

http://www.scotzine.com/2012/09/naismith-could-be-in-trouble-after-he-hits-out-at-serb/?

It's a f***ing elbow!

definately getting banned it is pretty bad

 

[D_Murph]

Even if he misses with his elbow and gets him with his forearm, your point is..............

 

[tim cahill]

Even if he misses with his elbow and gets him with his forearm, your point is..............

If he misses with his elbow then it isn't an elbow, simple.

 

[Arteta10]

Arteta10 you surprise me. i'm normally 'right with ya' on s**t like this, but you sound like a kopite on this one.
He's elbowed the lad in the face, it's just short of spitting at someone, or lunging with both feet off the floor, sh**house trick!

I dunno, I guess we're just gonna have to agree to disagree. I just can't find myself getting angry at an Everton player for doing something on the pitch to an opponent. What about Duncan's multiple incidents or Cahills chokehold on Alonso in the derby? Where do you stand on them? I just don't agree with the idea that Everton players have to play by the rules all the time when players from other clubs are doing similar stuff and getting away with it I think it's naive and counter productive, whether it's 'in the spirit of the game' or not. Win at all costs should be the mentality. You hate it when it's an oppo player doing it but you've gotta back your player when it's them!

 

[Arteta10]

And why do we all think he's definitely getting banned? How long ago was this? He hasn't played cos of injury for a year has he? Surely they're not gonna ban him for something that long ago

 

[tim cahill]

And why do we all think he's definitely getting banned? How long ago was this? He hasn't played cos of injury for a year has he? Surely they're not gonna ban him for something that long ago

It's only just happened mate.

 

[Tommy.]

Decent but not world class

Well, I guess that's us fu**ed then.

 

[tim-cahill-legend]

And why do we all think he's definitely getting banned? How long ago was this? He hasn't played cos of injury for a year has he? Surely they're not gonna ban him for something that long ago

was in the scotland v serbia game today mate

 

[Big Fat Sam]

He's ok imo, but not a world beater. I think he'll be good for six or seven goals this season if he starts regularly. Probably just below Osman's standard when Leon is at his best.

 

[D_Murph]

If he misses with his elbow then it isn't an elbow, simple.

I've watched it a few times, i think it's an elbow, but to back your argument up slightly, it might be his forearm. Either way Charlie Adam, El hadji diouf and Thiago Motta do sh** like this! Glasgow Rangers, scum of a club. Hail Hail.

 

[tim cahill]

In Glasgow a forearm to the face is a sign of friendship... so i've heard...

 

[Arteta10]

Oh my bad, I didn't watch the video properly, thought he was playing in a rangers shirt. Even so, if he gets banned it will be an international ban, no worries for us...unless FIFA realise he's an everton player!

 

[Neiler]

Go easy here lads with swearing and the Glasgow thing.

 

[nigelcoyb]

Swap Gerrard in the white of England doing it to Mirallas of Belgium and there wouldn't be a post in support.

Hypocrisy pure and simple.