2025/26 Jordan Pickford

[fitzyefc]

Horrendous. Kept us in the Premier league for a few seasons, forgiven.

Nearly relegated us. Will never be forgiven.

 

[duncs pigeon]

Nearly relegated us. Will never be forgiven.

Think the 10 players in front him nearly relegated us matey.

 

[fitzyefc]

They did Mr Pigeon and he was just as bad if not worse than most of them

 

[Toffeepot]

Last night showed why he is still here. Doesn't have the physicality or will to command his box and still produces the odd howler. Strangely enough saved us from more last night.

Every goalie produces the odd howler

 

[MACCA75]

They did Mr Pigeon and he was just as bad if not worse than most of them

Do you ever wonder why everyone keeps giving him player of the year awards and why he has 100 England caps? Is everyone else just wrong?

 

[fitzyefc]

Do you ever wonder why everyone keeps giving him player of the year awards and why he has 100 England caps? Is everyone else just wrong?

No cos alot of people dont rate him, he deserves his England caps cos he is Englands best keeper. Thats not a doubt. But he is still a bottom half keeper at very best. Phil Neville had 60 odd England caps and is in the top 5 worst players ive seen play for Everton.

I have said on here plenty my opinion why "some" Everton fans over rate him. I believe its because he was getting so much stick from the media they jumped to his defense and went the complete opposite and exagerate everthing he does Hes the only keeper i know who has shots right at him described as world class saves and "saving us from relgegation".

 

[MACCA75]

No cos alot of people dont rate him, he deserves his England caps cos he is Englands best keeper. Thats not a doubt. But he is still a bottom half keeper at very best. Phil Neville had 60 odd England caps and is in the top 5 worst players ive seen play for Everton.

I have said on here plenty my opinion why "some" Everton fans over rate him. I believe its because he was getting so much stick from the media they jumped to his defense and went the complete opposite and exagerate everthing he does Hes the only keeper i know who has shots right at him described as world class saves and "saving us from relgegation".

Phil Neville you think was one of the 5 worst players we’ve had? Right, ok.

 

[Bedfordblue]

 

[fitzyefc]

Phil Neville you think was one of the 5 worst players we’ve had? Right, ok.

Yes

 

[MACCA75]

Yes

That’s fine mate, no further questions.

 

[Toffeepot]

No cos alot of people dont rate him, he deserves his England caps cos he is Englands best keeper. Thats not a doubt. But he is still a bottom half keeper at very best. Phil Neville had 60 odd England caps and is in the top 5 worst players ive seen play for Everton.

I have said on here plenty my opinion why "some" Everton fans over rate him. I believe its because he was getting so much stick from the media they jumped to his defense and went the complete opposite and exagerate everthing he does Hes the only keeper i know who has shots right at him described as world class saves and "saving us from relgegation".

He would improve most teams in the league

If I was told I could only keep one player it would be him, not Branthwaite, not Ndiaye, and I love Skilliman

 

[Sharpies volley]

Ridiculous take

Explain.

 

[Sharpies volley]

Basics such as ? Shot stopping.

Weird take, seems a bit knee jerky

No, not shot stopping. I said he's good at shot stopping. I'm talking about the basics of goal keeping. Commanding your 6 yard box, claiming crosses. Gathering shots that come straight at you. Not rushing out like a looney and sometimes, half coming then going back.

 

[Sharpies volley]

Basics such as ? Shot stopping.

Weird take, seems a bit knee jerky

Also. Not knee jerky from me. I've criticised his basics since the 1st season he's been here.

 

[Saint Domingo]

Explain.

If his goalkeeping basics were some of the worst you’d ever seen in a keeper then I doubt he’d have 70 caps for England.