He's still far and away a better right back than Godfrey
2023/24 Seamus Coleman
- Thread starter ste d' indica
- Start date
hktoffee
Birds of a feather flock together
We should get rid of Young this summer.
Dymak
Player Valuation: £40m
Young, Coleman, Patterson and Godfrey should all go this summer imo. Yes, it would mean bringing in… replacements!
Last edited:
Hinchcliffe's Corner
Player Valuation: £35m
Shouldn't have been given a contract extension.
Arteta2391
Player Valuation: £30m
doesn't deserve the Old Yeller treatment...
I wonder if he never got the broken leg. I think he would have picked up way more points if he was playing out throughout all this dogshite time. Certainly I think his form would have not have dipped sort of like Cahill and Tim Howard kept starting for us way past their prime.
I wonder if he never got the broken leg. I think he would have picked up way more points if he was playing out throughout all this dogshite time. Certainly I think his form would have not have dipped sort of like Cahill and Tim Howard kept starting for us way past their prime.
Mrbluenose
Player Valuation: £8m
You are quick to defend Dele but won't extend the same courtesy to the club captain? A player who has paid for himself a 100 times over.
What a strange individual you are.
Hinchcliffe's Corner
Player Valuation: £35m
I'm not quick to say he should be playing for us and shouldn't be offered a new deal. I'm sorry that reading is hard for you old man. Neither players have contributed anything this season. Sentimentality has been the bane of our club for generations and you want to keep paying someone because they used to be good. Great logic.
DualityNSNO
How much for the pair?
Fair shout - he offers no contribution and was given a contract on an emotional basis.
As you say, sentimentality will be the bane of this club, jobs for the boys and all.
Hinchcliffe's Corner
Player Valuation: £35m
Let's not forget how incredible he's been for Everton, what a player in his prime probably the best right back in the league, however one year too far imo.
DualityNSNO
How much for the pair?
Won't even say one year - even last year he was dreadful for all but his last few games, the year before he was okay at best. Father time's caught up with him and he's had some dreadful injuries - loved him before but it's not 2016-2019 anymore, his prime's been gone and we should've replaced him ages ago (he also never learned to cross consistently, I've said this about him for about his entire time with us).
Is Patterson the answer/replacement? I dunno, we'll never know and we don't play with overlaps or attacking full backs - even Coleman himself in his prime would've looked garbage for current Everton as his best quality was bombing forward.
FWIW Baines retired when he was unable to physically meet the league's demands anymore, glad he didn't want a contract as he'd probably still be 2nd choice LB ffs
Hinchcliffe's Corner
Player Valuation: £35m
I thought Coleman, whilst a shade of his former self, was superb when he played last season, and was just what we needed on the field regarding leadership. Agree with the rest.
DualityNSNO
How much for the pair?
Early season he was asked to do more than he physically can - got ran past and outjumped quite a lot, and I have the sad memory of the mummified corpse of Shane Long beating him to a header he had no right to as well.
Hinchcliffe's Corner
Player Valuation: £35m
Hah I had forgotten that, there's so many bad memories from the last few years I can forgive him that one. He fought hard for us end of last year before the injury, scored a worldie as well.
DualityNSNO
How much for the pair?
Nah last few games he was fantastic truly, but I think that's the image of Coleman that people have for the entire season and it just wasn't the case.
He defo didn't mean it tho
Hinchcliffe's Corner
Player Valuation: £35m
Don't take that off us, he 100% meant it, if you don't say that you'll get fingers by the Irish on here
