Your best inconsistent 11

[toffeestillidie]

Make a starting 11 for your former or current everton players that were great on their best day, though average to terrible most of the time (for us or elsewhere). Sort of inspired by the "players that almost made it" thread

------------------Wright
--Neil ---Materazzi --- Billic ------GaryNaismith
-----------------Castillo
Van Der Meyde-----McFadden-----Bilyaletdinov
-----------Saha-----------Andy Johnson

 

[Goat]

AJ was a beast mate.

 

[Welton Toffee]

I liked Lucas Neill, wish he'd stayed a bit longer!

 

[snipellis11]

I thought Johnson was good for us to be honest.

 

[Azzurri]

I'm finding it hard to figure out who was inconsistent and who was consistently gash here.

 

[Ron Burgundy]

------------------Myhre-----------
Dunne------Bilic---------Materazzi----Pistone
---------------------------------
McFadden---Gemmill----Dacourt-----Bilyaletdinov
------------------------------------
-----------Saha-----Madar

 

[bluejock]

LEAVE MCFADDEN ALONE YOU BAD BUNCH OF BASTARDS

 

[Slavan]

I didnt think Materazzi was inconsistent, his main problem was the language barrier.

now mcfadden, that lad sums up inconsistency.

And the rangers fan in work says Naismith's biggest problem was inconsistency.

 

[Baines' left foot]

I'm finding it hard to figure out who was inconsistent and who was consistently gash here.

Mcfadden and Bily surely fall in to the latter category.

 

[mawders]

Gerrard
Xavier Tyler Bilic Pistone
Mcfadden Samways Billy
Bakayoko Amokachi Barlow

 

[Blue Wiz]

---------------------Myhre-------------------
Dunne-----Kroldrup-----Bilic-----Naysmith
Alexandersson--McFadden--Gravesen--VdM
----------Radzinski--------Saha-------------

Bench: Wright, Pistone, Linderoth, Bilyaletdinov, Drenthe, Jeffers, Beattie

 

[Fensta]

There are too many to list, can't fit them all into 1 team...

 

[DanEFC92]

---------------------Myhre-------------------
Dunne-----Kroldrup-----Bilic-----Naysmith
Alexandersson--McFadden--Gravesen--VdM
----------Radzinski--------Saha-------------

Bench: Wright, Pistone, Linderoth, Bilyaletdinov, Drenthe, Jeffers, Beattie

How can he be consistent or inconsistent if he only played one game for us?

 

[gheesom]

James Beattie anyone?

 

[toffeestillidie]

James Beattie anyone?

striker definitely gives the biggest selection headache for this, as nearly all of our recent strikers fall in this category (beattie, aj, saha, vaughan, yakubu).

it was pretty difficult to select a cb that fits the bill though, I guess that points to the general consistency of our defenders