Which player would be most disappointing if he leaves?

angelinsydney · January 17, 2011

Cahill. I don't want to lose The Head Master. I'm a bit panicked that lots of fans actually think there's not a place for Tim in the starting 11 when he comes back from the Asian Game. What to do???

Phenom · January 17, 2011

Fellaini, I think he would be harder to replace than anyone else, the guy is one of the best player in the league right now.

Bainsey not far behind tho.

toe · January 17, 2011

i misunderstood the thread, thought you meant who would be most dissapointing elsewhere (aka Lescott) If that was the meaning of the thread, then peanuts should be there. Wont be half the player everton made him elsewhere

TheBlueGibbon · January 17, 2011

Fellaini and Baines are neck and neck for me, with Cahill and Rodwell just behind.

Reidy's Bottle Of Grecian · January 17, 2011

toss up between Baines and Fellaini for me, due to age and ability, they will get better and I want it tro be with us when they peak.

Went for the big'un though.

chriswho · January 17, 2011

Blue Truth said:
i would go with this but everything good must come to an end so i would be more disappointed if something good came to an end prematurely.

This was my thought. Cahill is my favorite and I'd be gutted if he left, but I would be more disappointed if we lost Felliani as he is just coming into his own right now. I got scared during the off-season when he was seen at Real Madrid with Zidane... I want him to be successful, but I want it to be with us.

Cahill is having a great year this year, but I think his days of top class form are numbered at this point. I'll be happy to keep him hanging around as long as he wants, though I expect he will want to go play down under for a few years before he comes back up to Everton to manage. Be our own Dalglish...

Oxon · January 17, 2011

Surely Fellaini because he should be the heart of this team for years to come.

Losing Baines at this poitn would be devastating as well, though i don't think there is much risk of him leaving.

HSD · January 17, 2011

I think I would actually cry if Bainesy left.

Also, we need his legs - the little bambi.

He really is a player I think we need in our team, the effects of him leaving would be near to disastrous, IMO.

Blue 1 · January 17, 2011

Baines and Fellaini, but Fellaini edges it for me for a couple of reasons. He's 22 and already one of the best midfielders in the league. If we can keep hold of him could be the engine of our team for years to come.