I don't think the problem is who he plays at the moment. He could play Ronaldo and Messi because his tactics are so stale at the moment nothing seems to happen. There is so little movement off the ball that we end up throwing crosses into a box where, if we're lucky, our lone striker might show up, get pushed off the ball and we drop back to our own third of the pitch immediately.
Watch how everyone participating in that goal actually move without the ball. Even though we're only attacking with 3-4 people they're dominating that defense. And that's from Cahill, Baines, Pienaar and Osman, people I don't think we're applying the term 'quick' to generally. They just need to get movement back into their game, we can't continue being this static.
I have the same critiscism for the hoofball we play with Jags. If you've ever played football at the back, coming under pressure and no one's moving ahead of you, you'd have to be pretty relaxed/stupid to pass a short pass to some midfielder who's under pressure and with his back to the field and doesn't have anyone to pass to. You're just shifting responsibility, and being a ****ty teammate.