The mystery of Alex "Sandy" Young

Status
Not open for further replies.

Clint Planet

Utter Cad.
Not The Golden Vision of the sixties but the Alex Young who scored over 100 goals for us between 1901-11. I believe he was our most prolific scorer until Bill Dean arrived on the scene a couple of decades later. I'm fascinated by pre-WW1 footy in general and the men that played the game - the details of their careers are so sketchy, with people often having no idea about home many games they played for certain clubs or if they were there at all (Young seems to have been at Falkirk and St Mirren before travelling south to become Everton's goalscoring hero but, looking on Wiki, there are no stats for appearances).

But what makes Young particularly interesting is the mystery surrounding his life once he left Everton. It seems he played briefly for Spurs, Man City and South Liverpool but then it all gets even hazier. This is what Wiki has to say:

Post-playing life:Young was convicted of the manslaughter of his brother in Australia in June 1916 and sentenced to three years' imprisonment. The place, date and circumstances of his death are unclear. Either he was hanged for sheep-rustling in Australia or died in an Edinburgh asylum.

I'd love to know the truth. Anyone know of anything? Maybe there are more concrete facts in some book that I've not yet read.
 

I'm led to believe he hung in Australia for murdering his brother. The Echo ran an article on it earlier this year.
 
Wasn't there an old song 'Sandy scored a goal', when we won the cup in the early part of the 20th century(1908??).And before the jokes start...I was NOT there at the time.
 

I'm sure i read a thread on here not so long ago about this.

edit: it was in the echo. Duh.


Sandy Young myths have passed into Goodison folklore, with rumours abounding that the man whose goal brought the FA Cup back to Merseyside for the first time in 1906 was involved in something grim Down Under after hanging up his boots.

One report had him hanged for sheep rustling, others saw him admitted to an asylum after the manslaughter of his brother.

The truth, however, can be found on BlueCorrespondent.co.nr which seeks to reprint and upload every single Everton match report, preview and article ever written in our local papers.
 
Alexander "Sandy" Young. Born July 12th 1880, the son of a coalminer

Young joined from Falkirk in 1901, aged 21, debut against Villa on 28th September.

He scored the first ever derby hat trick when he netted 4 in the 1904 5-1 win at Goodison

Sandy scored the only goal of the 1906 FA Cup final at Crystal Palace when Everton played Newcastle. He netted 15 minutes from full time he smashed Jack Sharps cross passed the Newcastle keeper.

He top scored in England in 1906-07

His goalscoring record was unparralleled at Goodison until the arrival of Dixie dean scoring 125 goals in 314 games.

He is the forth highest goalscorer in Everton history, only Dean, Sharp and Latchford scored more.

In 1911 he was transferred to Tottenham where he scored 3 in his first 2 games. He failed to score in the next two games so was dropped. As a result he demanded a transfer and subsequently made a swift return to the north west to play for Man City and then South Liverpool.

He was however unsettled and decided to emigrate to Australia.

He had earlier lent his brother £150 to go to Australia, and when he to emigrated, he joined his brother on his farm outside Melbourne and subsequently lent him a further £175 (a large sum of money in those days).

Sandy didn't get on well with his brother John who was violent and threatening, the issue of the loan of money rankled between them and they had frequent fights, one evening on 31st November 1915, John again threatened Sandy, "You or me will have to enter Heaven tonight".

After an acrimonous parting and an uneasy night's sleep, Sandy heard a noise, and fearing his brother quickly grabbed a double barrelled shotgun and loaded it. He found his brother John in the cow shed where he was milking and the argument quickly resumed. John picked up a shovel and again threatened Sandy.

Sandy ran out of the shed but John chased him, after about 40 yards Sandy stopped and turned to face his brother pointing the gun "Stand or I will fire"

John swung the shovel, Sandy fired and his brother fell to the ground.

Leaving John lying mortally wounded on the ground, Sandy Picked up the shovel and carried it with the gun into the kitchen
where he sat at the kitchen table put the shotgun against his face and pulled the trigger.

He survived and after a spell in hospital he was put on trial for the murder of his brother.

Sandy was found not guilty of murder, but he was convicted of manslaughter, helped a great deal by Everton who telegrammed to his lawyers statements to the effect that he was prone to "fits of temporary insanity" as a player for them.

He served three years in jail for manslaughter but was kept in asylums after the sentence expired due to mental weakness.

He did however eventually return to his native Scotland where he died in Edinburgh on September 18th 1959 due to cardiovascular degeneration.

A life touched by greatness and tragedy.

Alexander Simpson Young
July 12th 1880 - September 18th 1959

v0_medium.jpg



written by me from extensive research from multiple sources and original archives!, there isn't anything else as comprehensive on the internet that I'm aware of.

The only thing original I've ever really written.
 
Fantastic, Mark. Thank you very much, and hats off to you.

I get the feeling it would make a great book or film, Sandy's story. I also find myself wondering about what happened in all those years following his conviction and sentence and before his death (he was, after all, 79 at the time of his death). I wonder how many people knew of his illustrious past. I wonder how much he talked of it. I wonder how much he was believed. I find myself more concerned with the man, rather than the player.
 

His death certificate listed his profession as "professional footballer" 45 years after he'd retired.

That was a fitting tribute.

My son is named after him, but don't tell the mrs
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top