I think Moyes has looked completely clueless for a lot of the last couple of seasons.
My guess is he's just run out of ideas, so he's reverting to type by sticking with players who have performed for him in the past (Jags, Cahill etc) regardless of form, and setting us up to be hard to beat.
Trouble is, its just not working this time, and I don't know if he's got it in him to shake things up like I think we all agree he needs to if we're going to see improvements on the pitch.
Moyes out? Hmmmm. Maybe. Honestly not sure if I would trust him to put a new team together now. Too many strange/stupid decisions lately for me. This team won't be kept together much longer due to retirements and the inevitable loss of some of our better players (Fellaini in particular) now that its obvious we're not going to be a force in Europe again any time soon.
Hope I'm proved wrong on that last point, obviously, but I'd be surprised.