Pundits who are former players

[Professor Toffee]

who's your favourite football pundit who's an ex professional footballer
My only one is Johnny Giles , who covers Ireland matches with the brain dead Dunphy and Brady
Least favourite?
Phil Thompson, the get

 

[Yid4life]

Best Jenas

Worst Merson

 

[summerisle]

Derek Mountfield did a few games some years ago. Wonder what he's doing nowadays?

 

[Khalekan]

who's your favourite football pundit who's an ex professional footballer
My only one is Johnny Giles , who covers Ireland matches with the brain dead Dunphy and Brady
Least favourite?
Phil Thompson, the get

Does the Poison Dwarf count?

If so I nominate Dunphy

And I wish the ORTE panel was on English TV.....it is way better than the horrible buggers we have to put up with.

 

[Khalekan]

Best Jenas

Worst Merson

I think Jenas has been very good any time I have seen him.

The most bland?

Garth Crooks without a doubt

 

[Dithering Dougie]

Can't look past Neville surely?

After him Kilbane, Jenas and (guilty secret) Souness.


The worst has to be either Henry or Redknapp.

I'd imagine the person who decided to hire Henry on such a long and lucrative contract is now unemployed.

 

[Khalekan]

Can't look past Neville surely?

After him Kilbane, Jenas and (guilty secret) Souness.


The worst has to be either Henry or Redknapp.

I'd imagine the person who decided to hire Henry on such a long and lucrative contract is now unemployed.

I like Souness as a talking head too.

 

[Caolam]

Favourite was Martin O Neill, wasn't afraid to speak his mind, probably why he isn't on any more. Also like Keane, while I don't always agree with what he says at least he does speak his mind. I want pundits to say what they think, to have an opinion not to say what they think is acceptable. I question I would pose to people who watch football programs and who discuss football with their mates is "how often do you and your mates disagree on football". My experience is it happens all the time, look at this forum.
TV pundits might differ slightly but generally they all sing from the one script, TV companies don't want unsightly arguments on screen. That isn't how it works, we like football because it is about opinions, we can all have our say. TV punditry is sanitizing the debate and should be ignored.

I reserve my real dislike for the plastic Irishman and Alan Hansen 's pet monkey.

 

[EDINHO1]

I like Jenas and Don Goodman.

Martin keown is appalling.

 

[Jamo Martinez]

Can't look past Neville surely?

After him Kilbane, Jenas and (guilty secret) Souness.


The worst has to be either Henry or Redknapp.

I'd imagine the person who decided to hire Henry on such a long and lucrative contract is now unemployed.

Apparently they were in the studio for our game yesterday.

Ex Arsenal and ex rs players to analise a Spurs v Everton match. You couldn't make it up.

 

[Lids1978]

who's your favourite football pundit who's an ex professional footballer
My only one is Johnny Giles , who covers Ireland matches with the brain dead Dunphy and Brady
Least favourite?
Phil Thompson, the get

Giles is woeful and should've packed in pundit duties years ago. Dunphy was amusing when I was young but like Giles is outta touch with the modern club games and should've packed in long ago.

 

[Lids1978]

[QUOTE="Caolam, post: 3825410, member

I reserve my real dislike for the plastic Irishman and Alan Hansen 's pet monkey.[/QUOTE]
Who's that mate?

 

[Lids1978]

[QUOTE="Caolam, post: 3825410, member

I reserve my real dislike for the plastic Irishman and Alan Hansen 's pet monkey.

Who's that mate?[/QUOTE]
Its Lawrenson surely!

 

[Caolam]

Who's that mate?

Its Lawrenson surely![/QUOTE]
The one and only.

 

[Lids1978]

Can't look past Neville surely?

After him Kilbane, Jenas and (guilty secret) Souness.


The worst has to be either Henry or Redknapp.

I'd imagine the person who decided to hire Henry on such a long and lucrative contract is now unemployed.

Don't like Neville anymore mate. He's made the list of ex pros who've tried to push through Stones to Chelsea. Merson is actually nearly crying in one of today's papers over it lol