player ratings

[devonblue]

hope this allowed in new thread.
howard 7 steady game

hibbert 6 improved second half when paired with pienaar

neill 5 defended well but distribution was poor

heitinga 6 solid but a little casual at times

baines 6 decent game and well taken penalty

peanut 7 technically our best player faded in second half

neville 5 poor game from the skipper but nice to see him back

fellaini 8 ran the show tireless running and commitment

bily4 seemed completely lost

cahill 5 poor game but well taken goal

vaughan 7 good energy from someone who has been out for so long and well taken goal

subs
coleman 7 looks a good prospect
agard 6 good pace and running should have come on earlier

in all a poor game but good result

 

[quasi modo]

Cahill and Bily bad games again, yet both will play against arsenal.

 

[devonblue]

Cahill and Bily bad games again, yet both will play against arsenal.

can see bily being rested for osman if he's fit and donovan for cahill
although cahill's goal may reprieve him

 

[Goat]

Howard - 8 - Got down nicely and behind a few tasty shots.
Hibbert -1 - Close to the worst player ive seen play for Everton EVER
Baines - 7 - He did ok
Neil - 8 - Another good game, I love the way he brings the ball out of D
Heintinga - 8 - The Rock
Pienaar - 7 - Wasnt really happening for him today
Billy - 4 - Really bad
Fellaini - 9 - Superb
Neville - 7 - Average
Cahill - 7 - Average
Vaughan - 9 - Great job of leading the line, movement was great.

Coleman - 10 - Great stuff again

 

[best little spaniard]

So, will Vaughan make it?

 

[Goat]

If he stays injury free of course he will, the talent is there, so much talent, so much energy. Imagine if he had an injury free 2-3 years, he would be some player by now.

 

[devonblue]

Howard - 8 - Got down nicely and behind a few tasty shots.
Hibbert -1 - Close to the worst player ive seen play for Everton EVER
Baines - 7 - He did ok
Neil - 8 - Another good game, I love the way he brings the ball out of D
Heintinga - 8 - The Rock
Pienaar - 7 - Wasnt really happening for him today
Billy - 4 - Really bad
Fellaini - 9 - Superb
Neville - 7 - Average
Cahill - 7 - Average
Vaughan - 9 - Great job of leading the line, movement was great.

Coleman - 10 - Great stuff again

have to agree coleman was mustard yesterday

 

[best little spaniard]

If he stays injury free of course he will, the talent is there, so much talent, so much energy. Imagine if he had an injury free 2-3 years, he would be some player by now.

I was thinking that, but the question is the injuries.

He could be right up there by now couldn't he? It makes you sad really.

 

[devonblue]

I was thinking that, but the question is the injuries.

He could be right up there by now couldn't he? It makes you sad really.

i remember feeling the same about barlow jeffers cadamateri branch

 

[quasi modo]

i remember feeling the same about barlow jeffers cadamateri branch

Never with Branch, he was awful.