Player Ratings versus Chelsea September 12th

Status
Not open for further replies.
Professor Toffee

Professor Toffee

On and on, over the hill and the craic is good
my own impressions today, ecpxcellent in defence, team well set up and coped with loss of Besic in some style
Howard 6 didn't have much to do but wasn't convincing
Coleman 8 good raiding , good control sub Mori n/a looked classy
Jagielka 8 stronger formate, good double teaming
Stones 9 awesome
Galloway 9 superb, poise and confidence
Besic n/a sub Naismith 10 - marvellous scored 1st ever hatrick v a Mourinho Chelsea
McCarthy 7 efficient, broke play up well
Barry 8 good game complemented McCarthy well, some passing not great
Barkley 7 played well but still delays some passes
Kone 8 good in defence, good running forward, some dumb passes sub Lennon 7
Lukaku 7 efficient but non thrreatening
 

Professor Toffee said:
my own impressions today, ecpxcellent in defence, team well set up and coped with loss of Besic in some style
Howard 6 didn't have much to do but wasn't convincing
Coleman 8 good raiding , good control sub Mori n/a looked classy
Jagielka 8 stronger formate, good double teaming
Stones 9 awesome
Besic n/a sub Naismith 10 - marvellous scored 1st ever hatrick v a Mourinho Chelsea
McCarthy 7 efficient, broke play up well
Barry 8 good game complemented McCarthy well, some passing not great
Barkley 7 played well but still delays some passes
Kobe 8 good in defence, good running forward, some dumb passes
Lukaku 7 efficient but non thrreatening
Click to expand...
Barkley needs at least another mark.
 
Howard 6
Coleman 9
Jagielka 8
Stones 8
Galloway 8
McCarthy 7
Barry 8
Barkley 9
Kone 8
Lukaku 6
Naismith 10
Lennon 7

Thought Mori looked good too but wasn't on long enough. Howard's 6 because of how little he had to do not due to performance.
 
Robertor said:
Howard 6
Coleman 9
Jagielka 8
Stones 8
Galloway 8
McCarthy 7
Barry 8
Barkley 9
Kone 8
Lukaku 6
Naismith 10
Lennon 7

Thought Mori looked good too but wasn't on long enough. Howard's 6 because of how little he had to do not due to performance.
Click to expand...
Pretty much agree with this. Could argue which of Coleman, Stones or Galloway deserves the 9. Spot on with Rom too. Some parts of his game are great but he really lets himself down with his ball control and cumbersome link up play.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
cduff said:
Pretty much agree with this. Could argue which of Coleman, Stones or Galloway deserves the 9. Spot on with Rom too. Some parts of his game are great but he really lets himself down with his ball control and cumbersome link up play.

REGISTERSIGN IN
FOOTBALL
ADVERTISEMENT
7 SEP 2015 - 10:36PM
Shearer slams Van Gaal


Header_Wedge_Football_Mobile_2b.png




1
United currently sits fifth in the Premier League table with seven points from four games and Shearer is not impressed with its performances so far this campaign, stressing that Sunday morning's (AEST) match against Liverpool is a must-win for the Old Trafford side.

"I would argue Louis van Gaal cannot even afford to draw the game against Liverpool," Shearer writes for The Sun.

"He has been asking for more time for his team to blend, for young players to develop etc. Time is up I'm afraid - the time is now.

"You cannot oversee the changes he has made, backed by hundreds of millions, and then claim you are a victim because it needs time to blend. It is your job to mould a side and I would suggest a year is plenty for a club of Manchester United's standing.

"You can get away with the dull, functional football Van Gaal is dishing up if you are getting results. But if you go back to the end of last season, Van Gaal's league run over the last 10 games now stands at four wins, three draws and three defeats.

"Van Gaal's CV has afforded him the time that David Moyes was not given. But a poor result on Saturday and questions will start to be asked."

United last won the Premier League title in 2012-13 and have since had to settle for seventh and fourth place in the table.

  • More Videos
Browse by



Powered by Livefyre
ADVERTISEMENT
TRENDING FOOTBALL
Matildas go on strike to put USA games in jeopardy
Iran stars in tattoo trouble
Taggart on target but Olyroos fall to Aussie led FYR Macedonia
6 things to look out for when the Socceroos face Tajikistan
Balotelli denies making Real Madrid 'joke'
Best of SBS




nup_164298_1641.jpg


DRAMA
Watch DIG: new from the creator of Heroes





6e0f1d0a-55fa-4b44-b257-01fb86e43f9e.jpeg

COMEDY
Melbourne vs Sydney: the ultimate showdown





600-movies-top-promo-logo-318x265.jpg


MOVIES
Free! More than 600 movies to watch now





456074307705_06031206_deathrow_1_networktile.jpg


DOCUMENTARY
Movie director chats with Death Row killers





ob3_ep301_d5_nov11_sw_0172.jpg


DRAMA
Online early! Watch Orphan Black series 3


Where There's a Will
Peloton cracks on steep slopes of Ermita de Alba
Comment: A new way to test your 'biological' age
20 misused English words that make smart people look silly
Apple to unveil two new iPhones, iPad Pro
Stay Connected with SBS
Newsletter
SUBSCRIBE NOW
Podcasts
LISTEN NOW
RSS
SUBSCRIBE NOW
Apps
DOWNLOAD APPLE
DOWNLOAD ANDROID
IN SOCIAL

Follow
Twitter
97K


Subscribe
Facebook
242.5K


Follow
Google+
0.9K


Watch
YouTube
2.8K

ADVERTISEMENT

Back to top
hr Coleman, Stones
Click to expand...

WTF? lol
 

Barkley definitely a 9....two assists and retained the ball amazingly under pressure all game...his performance as a No 10 yesterday was better than any potential signing we would have made
 
Howard - 6
Coleman - 8
Stones - 9
Jags - 8
Galloway - 8
McCarthy - 7
Barry - 7
Naismith - 9
Barkley - 8
Kone - 7
Lukaku - 6

My students always complain I give low grades.
 

Howard - 7
Coleman - 7.5
Stones - 8.5
Jags - 8
Galloway 8

Stones stood out head and shoulders above the rest of the defence - none had anything less than a decent game..

McCarthy - 7.5
Barry - 8
Besic - N/A
Naismith - 9
Barkley - 8

All decent, did their job to the required level and snuffed out Chelsea (mind you, Chelsea did a fair job of doing that for themselves)

Kone - 8
Lukaku - 7

Simply because they didn't hit the net doesn't make for a poor effort. Both carried the load well. Kone found Coleman well and wasted nothing, almost scored with a decent header. Lukaku became a more isolated figure when the game was tight but still caused trouble and did well late on.

Lennon 7, RFM 7
 
cduff said:
Pretty much agree with this. Could argue which of Coleman, Stones or Galloway deserves the 9. Spot on with Rom too. Some parts of his game are great but he really lets himself down with his ball control and cumbersome link up play.

REGISTERSIGN IN
FOOTBALL
ADVERTISEMENT
7 SEP 2015 - 10:36PM
Shearer slams Van Gaal


Header_Wedge_Football_Mobile_2b.png




1
United currently sits fifth in the Premier League table with seven points from four games and Shearer is not impressed with its performances so far this campaign, stressing that Sunday morning's (AEST) match against Liverpool is a must-win for the Old Trafford side.

"I would argue Louis van Gaal cannot even afford to draw the game against Liverpool," Shearer writes for The Sun.

"He has been asking for more time for his team to blend, for young players to develop etc. Time is up I'm afraid - the time is now.

"You cannot oversee the changes he has made, backed by hundreds of millions, and then claim you are a victim because it needs time to blend. It is your job to mould a side and I would suggest a year is plenty for a club of Manchester United's standing.

"You can get away with the dull, functional football Van Gaal is dishing up if you are getting results. But if you go back to the end of last season, Van Gaal's league run over the last 10 games now stands at four wins, three draws and three defeats.

"Van Gaal's CV has afforded him the time that David Moyes was not given. But a poor result on Saturday and questions will start to be asked."

United last won the Premier League title in 2012-13 and have since had to settle for seventh and fourth place in the table.

  • More Videos
Browse by



Powered by Livefyre
ADVERTISEMENT
TRENDING FOOTBALL
Matildas go on strike to put USA games in jeopardy
Iran stars in tattoo trouble
Taggart on target but Olyroos fall to Aussie led FYR Macedonia
6 things to look out for when the Socceroos face Tajikistan
Balotelli denies making Real Madrid 'joke'
Best of SBS




nup_164298_1641.jpg


DRAMA
Watch DIG: new from the creator of Heroes





6e0f1d0a-55fa-4b44-b257-01fb86e43f9e.jpeg

COMEDY
Melbourne vs Sydney: the ultimate showdown





600-movies-top-promo-logo-318x265.jpg


MOVIES
Free! More than 600 movies to watch now





456074307705_06031206_deathrow_1_networktile.jpg


DOCUMENTARY
Movie director chats with Death Row killers





ob3_ep301_d5_nov11_sw_0172.jpg


DRAMA
Online early! Watch Orphan Black series 3


Where There's a Will
Peloton cracks on steep slopes of Ermita de Alba
Comment: A new way to test your 'biological' age
20 misused English words that make smart people look silly
Apple to unveil two new iPhones, iPad Pro
Stay Connected with SBS
Newsletter
SUBSCRIBE NOW
Podcasts
LISTEN NOW
RSS
SUBSCRIBE NOW
Apps
DOWNLOAD APPLE
DOWNLOAD ANDROID
IN SOCIAL

Follow
Twitter
97K


Subscribe
Facebook
242.5K


Follow
Google+
0.9K


Watch
YouTube
2.8K

ADVERTISEMENT

Back to top
hr Coleman, Stones
Click to expand...
Mods?
 
Howard - 7 did not have enough to do to warrant more
Coleman - 8 coped well defensively and had a few forays forward
Galloway - 9 Great game, looked untroubled throughout
Jags - 9 strings in the tackle and in the air
Stones - 10 nuff said
McCarthy - 7 need to show more offensively
Barry - 8 broke up play well started a few forward moves
Barkley - 8 showed lots of promise looking good for the season
Naismith - 10 hat trick !!!!!
Kone - 8 good defensively apart from one howler, looked competent
Lukaku - 7 sort of missed out as Naismith stole the show

Besic n/a
Lennon didn't make a big enough impact
Funes Mori tantalising cameo
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top