Neville OR Hibbert

BlueTornado · August 30, 2011

TONY, TONY TONY, TONY TONY HIBBERT!

MapleLeafEvertonian · August 30, 2011

Number_25 said:
It has to be Neville, his leadership qualities are there. The Blackburn game shows that if you have proper leadership on the pitch nothing is impossible. Hibbert is useful but his passing can be a bit wayward and his positioning is a bit off.

Coleman for RM, I only wish we had another on the left!

Yeah...not the best example you could have used there...

DualityNSNO · August 30, 2011

TX Bill said:
Hibbert for pure defending.

Hibbert barely edges Neville on crossing.

Neville barely edges Hibbert on passing.

Hibbert for me.

This...

RadioFriendlyUnitShifter said:
Are you taking the piss mate?

We were disorganised, dysfunctional and generally useless against Blackburn. Everyone looked like they were playing together for the first time.

The only reasons we didn't lose -- and lose badly -- were because Howard bailed us out, Blackburn were wasteful and the ref gifted us a pen. Nev's "leadership qualities" had nothing to do with it. In fact said qualities were not present at all.

...and this.

wabisabi · August 30, 2011

Neville has more nous. Hibberts one good point is when he does those full on sliding tackles. If we're honest both are little more than mediocre. Hibberts dreadful slo-mo floated crosses* means Nev gets my vote.

*league 1 standard

Carl Hankin · August 30, 2011

hibbo has more passion to be a Everton player,and see us succeed,phil nev has done it all..

MapleLeafEvertonian · September 10, 2011

Bumpity bump.

So Hibbert got 90 minutes today? How do people feel he did? Have him over pip?

met069 · September 10, 2011

His crosses weren't great, but at least he wasn't floating them in. They actually looked like crosses.

Hibbert in!

Silas · September 10, 2011

MapleLeafEvertonian said:
Bumpity bump.

So Hibbert got 90 minutes today? How do people feel he did? Have him over pip?

Great first half, stood off his man too much second but still miles better than Neville.

Zatara · September 10, 2011

GrandOldTeam said:
Simple thread, simple poll - given a choice between the two, who do you opt for?

Why no option for Coleman ?

He looks very good at right midfield BUT he should soon move back into right back -- Moyes said Coleman would be played more at right back this season.

Phenom · September 10, 2011

Hibbert.

Hibbert&Ernie · September 10, 2011

Hibbert was picked for speed today, with Agbonlahor and N'Zogbia is their line up, they were always going to look to expose our flanks, as it stood, Hibbert allowed Coleman to push up and over Warnock thereby nullifying Agbon especially in the first half. A stronger referee would have eventually booked Warnock then it would have been a very different game.