Ireland squad or Scottish squad,which is better?

EFC David · August 26, 2014

everthong said:
Seeing as the quailfiers for euro 2016 are starting shortly and that Ireland and Scotland are in the same group I'd like to know which squad the Everton fans would rate higher. Don't take form or World rankings into consideration, just which is the better starting XI and Squad.

Ireland
David Forde (Millwall)
Coleman-O'Shea (Sunderland)-Damian Delaney(Palace)-Marc Wilson (Stoke)
James McCarthy-Darron Gibson
McGeady Robbie Brady(Hull)
Wes Hoolahan(Norwich)
Robbie Keane (La Galaxy)

Subs:Westwood(Sheff Wed)
Shane Long (Southampton)
Joey O'Brein (Westham)
Ciaran Clark (Villa)
Shane Duffy
Glenn Whelan (Stoke)
Jon Walters (Stoke)
Will Buckley (Sunderland)
David Meyler (Hull)
Stepehen Quinn (Hull)
Paul McShane (Hull)
Jeff Hendrick (Derby)
Andy Reid (Forrest)
Anthony Pilkington (Cardiff)
James McClean (Wigan)
Anthony Stokes (Celtic)
Stephen Ward (Burnley)

Scotland:
McGregor (Hull)
Hutton (Villa)-Hanley(BlackBurn)-Martin(Norwich)-Robertson(Hull)
Fletcher(United)-Brown(Celtic)
Anya(Watford)---Naismith---Snodgrass(Hull)
Fletcher (Sunderland)
Subs:
Craig Gordon (Celtic)
David Marshall (Cardiff City)
Christophe Berra (Ipswich Town)
Craig Forsyth (Derby County)
Gordon Greer (Brighton and Hove Albion)
Steven Whittaker (Norwich City)
Ikechi Anya (Watford)
Barry Bannan (Crystal Palace)
Craig Bryson (Derby County)
Chris Burke (Nottingham Forest)
Graham Dorrans (West Bromwich Albion)
Shaun Maloney (Wigan Athletic)
James McArthur (Wigan Athletic)
Kevin McDonald (Wolverhampton Wanderers)
Callum McGregor (Celtic)
James Morrison (West Bromwich Albion)
Charlie Mulgrew (Celtic)
Chris Martin (Derby County)
Rhodes( BlackBurn)
McCormack (Fulham)

You have Anya twice.

Scotland's is more balanced, Morrison is our captain so he'll start.

It would be nice if James Morrison and Chris Martin did a duet.