Haiti rejects Dominican Republic troops-envoys

Status
Not open for further replies.
L

Lisa

Guest
UNITED NATIONS (Reuters) - Earthquake-ravaged Haiti turned down an offer of troops from the neighbouring Dominican Republic, forcing the United Nations to look elsewhere for additional peacekeepers, U.N. diplomats said on Wednesday.
The Dominican Republic had offered an 800-strong battalion to form part of the reinforcement of the U.N. peacekeeping mission in Haiti.
"We understand the Haitian government has said no to them," one Western diplomat said on condition of anonymity. He said he assumed the decision came from Haitian President Rene Preval.
The two states share the Caribbean island of Hispaniola but have a history of tense relations.
A U.N. official confirmed that Haiti turned down the offer but said the decision might not be definitive and talks were under way to see if Haiti would allow a rescue team or police from the Dominican Republic to help with the relief efforts.
"We're hoping other countries can provide troops," the official said.
The full potential strength of the U.N. peacekeeping force is now 12,651, up from the current level of around 9,000, after a U.N. Security Council resolution adopted on Tuesday.
The United Nations is now rushing to find the extra 3,651 troops and police to help maintain security and deliver aid.


Edmond Mulet, sent to Haiti to take over the U.N. force after its chief, Hedi Annabi, and dozens of other U.N. staff died in the earthquake, has said that Brazil was offering more troops and France and Chile were offering police.
U.N. officials have said the Philippines might also top up its existing contingent.
Haitian officials say the death toll from the Jan. 12 quake was likely to be between 100,000 and 200,000, and that 75,000 bodies had already been buried in mass graves.
The United States has around 12,000 military personnel in Haiti, on ships offshore or en route. They are not under U.N. command, though they are cooperating with the United Nations, which is overseeing the relief effort
 

Personally I don't think they should be turning down help. I understand they have had issues with Dominican Republic in the past. But they have offered to help, they should take it!! They have so many people still trapped, most I know will probably be dead at this point, but they still need the extra help........
 
Personally I don't think they should be turning down help. I understand they have had issues with Dominican Republic in the past. But they have offered to help, they should take it!! They have so many people still trapped, most I know will probably be dead at this point, but they still need the extra help........

You have to think of the citizens of Haiti.. If they dont like the dominicans than sending troops from said country could cause more distress.. It would be like the U.S. sending troops to Iran to help in a search and recue operation..
 
Except many of them are crossing the border to be treated at hospitals in the Dominican Republic. President Leonel Fernandez ordered border hospitals to open their doors to let injured men, women and children in. Critically ill have been airlifted to their hospitals, they are over flowing with people from Haiti...........
 
Surely this was a chance to build bridges in a time of great need. It makes no sense to stick to old traditions and hatred, when they need the urgent assistance.
It just goes to show, that those in power dont care about the needs of the people.
 

Surely this was a chance to build bridges in a time of great need. It makes no sense to stick to old traditions and hatred, when they need the urgent assistance.
It just goes to show, that those in power dont care about the needs of the people.


My thoughts exactly!
 
After Hurricane Katrina, Cuba offered teams and equipment who are experts at dealing with the aftermath of a hurricane and the US refused it.


Politics and humanity never run hand in hand. Yet it is the politicians that always call for humanitarian help.


Dual edges all the way down the sword.
 
Personally I don't think they should be turning down help. I understand they have had issues with Dominican Republic in the past. But they have offered to help, they should take it!! They have so many people still trapped, most I know will probably be dead at this point, but they still need the extra help........

I'd love to agree with you, but understanding the nature of the bad history between the two peoples, troops would be a very bad idea, especially if things turned nasty, such as food riots, which have been remarkably few.

I don't think that it would be remiss to provide more nurses etc, but believe me, the tensions relate to the very foundation of both states.
 

Would a drowning Haitian refuse help from a Dominican who was in a position to save him.................of course not.

Normally speaking troubles between nations lie with governments, hardly ever the people, unless one lot is French.........ask some one who needs help if they care where it comes from they'd surely accept it. IMO the Haiti government doesn't have the right to refuse as to a degree their corruption over the years has only served to weaken the fragile infrastructure in that country that has now fallen apart like a pack of playing cards
 
Last edited:
Would a drowning Haitian refuse help from a Dominican who was in a position to save him.................of course not.

Normally speaking troubles between nations lie with governments, hardly ever the people, unless one lot is French.........ask some one who needs help if they care where it comes from they'd surely accept it. IMO the Haiti government does have the right to refuse as to a degree there corruption over the years has only served to weaken the fragile infrastructure in that country that has now fallen apart

haha (y)
 
Would a drowning Haitian refuse help from a Dominican who was in a position to save him.................of course not.

Normally speaking troubles between nations lie with governments, hardly ever the people, unless one lot is French.........ask some one who needs help if they care where it comes from they'd surely accept it. IMO the Haiti government doesn't have the right to refuse as to a degree their corruption over the years has only served to weaken the fragile infrastructure in that country that has now fallen apart like a pack of playing cards

I'm not trying to make light of the situation, but its the differnce between "I'll help you then go away" and "I'll help you, but I want to have sex with your daughter" - one you'd except willingly, the other, you'd need to be at deaths door to agree to.

As I said, medical help would be acceptable, but troops would be very, very volatile given the nature of how both countries were founded.
 
I'm not trying to make light of the situation, but its the differnce between "I'll help you then go away" and "I'll help you, but I want to have sex with your daughter" - one you'd except willingly, the other, you'd need to be at deaths door to agree to.

As I said, medical help would be acceptable, but troops would be very, very volatile given the nature of how both countries were founded.


BT like you I'm treating this seriously but unfortunately the state Haiti is in (it was bad enough before the quake) you could say that the daughter has been had a few times. In no way should the Dom troops remain but if law and order breaks down (and they didn't have much to start with) it becomes a problem for the international community, you can't have aid workers being threatened with machetes while trying to save people
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top