Everton vs Them - Match Report and MotM Poll...

Everton Man of the Match

  • Maarten Stekelenburg

    Votes: 1 0.6%
  • Joel Robles

    Votes: 2 1.2%
  • Leighton Baines

    Votes: 4 2.5%
  • Ramiro Funes Mori

    Votes: 11 6.8%
  • Ashley Williams

    Votes: 3 1.9%
  • Seamus Coleman

    Votes: 62 38.5%
  • Idrissa Gana Gueye

    Votes: 48 29.8%
  • James McCarthy

    Votes: 16 9.9%
  • Ross Barkley

    Votes: 7 4.3%
  • Aaron Lennon

    Votes: 1 0.6%
  • Enner Valencia

    Votes: 1 0.6%
  • Romelu Lukaku

    Votes: 1 0.6%
  • Gareth Barry

    Votes: 2 1.2%
  • Dominic Calvert-Lewin

    Votes: 2 1.2%

  • Total voters
    161
Status
Not open for further replies.

AndyC

Player Valuation: £70m
Apologies for the delay, massively delayed in traffic on the way home...

Derby hoodoo strikes again.

Everton 0 - 1 Them

Brief Summary…A highly charged ‘derby’ went the way of the visitors as Everton ran out of gas and Sadio Mane pounced in the 94th minute to wreck Ronald Koeman’s home record..

Another evening game under the Grand Old Lady’s lights – how many more will there be for us to enjoy - and Blues fans keen to go into Christmas with smiles on our faces with victory over ‘them’ to enjoy along with the turkey, mince pies and the occasional tipple or three.

Ronald Koeman selected his first derby line-up: Stekelenburg, Baines, Williams, Funes Mori, Coleman, Gueye, Barkley, McCarthy, Lennon, Valencia and Lukaku.

Klippity lined ‘them’ up: Mignolet, Clyne, Lovren, Klavan, Milner, Henderson, Wijnaldum, Lallana, Firmino, Origi and Mane.

The Wirral’s’ Mike Dean was the referee under close scrutiny given his recent record of red card waving.

A passionate atmosphere saw a frenetic opening with Everton biting into the tackle and unsettling ‘them’ right from the off. A Coleman cross saw Lovren clear with a hurried header and the Blues were pressuring ‘them’ closing quickly and playing with great energy.

Valencia set Rom free down the right but his cross was too strong and went to safety. Everton wasted a free kick following a Firmino foul on Valencia and Lovren made a key block as Ross tried to release Rom through the left side.

Everton were much the better side through the first twenty minutes and a nice move involving Lennon and Barkley saw Klavan make a telling block to foil Lukaku while Klippity raged on the side-line

With half an hour gone and neither goalie tested in the slightest, Everton eased up and ‘they’ began to get a foothold into the game, but RFM outfought Orighi before another right wing move saw a cross from Coleman appear to hit the hand of Horrendouson only for referee Mike Dean to wave away half-hearted penalty claims.

They countered and arguably the best chance of the first half so far saw Orighi do his Mesut Ozil impersonation spooning a shot high and wide into the Street End.

The hard-working James McCarthy, who had had a fine first half hour, went down on 38 minutes and needed treatment for cramp. As the first half wound down, the Blues won the game’s first corner kick and the cross from Ross saw RFM find space for a free header that really should have hit the target.

Half Time: 0-0

Gareth Barry replaced Jimmy Mac for the second half and good as player as he is, Gaz Baz hasn’t the high energy game that McCarthy had employed to such good effect in tandem with the ever-industrious Gana Gueye.

The loss of McCarthy was seized upon by ‘them’ as they upped their effort and forced Aaron Lennon into a hurried and miscued clearance for their first corner.

Some rather hurried and desperate defending was needed when Firmino worked a left flank opening and Stekelenburg made an instinctive save but the ball went pin balling around the area before eventually being cleared to safety.

Gana broke up an attack to release Barkley through midfield where he was bundled off the ball by Firmino who avoided a yellow card. Barry sent a long chip over the top for Lukaku but his header cleared the crossbar.

Referee Mike Dean finally brandished yellow on 55 minutes as Lovren blatantly blocked Lukaku turning sweetly on a short ball from Barkley.

The next major incident saw Baines and Stekelenburg collide painfully for the goalie in denying Mane, with a long delay before play resumed, and that eventually saw him limp out of the game to be replaced by Joel Robles on 63 minutes.

Tempers came close to fraying a couple of minutes later as Barkley went in late on Horrendouson and Lovren raced twenty yards to stick his ugly oar in, Seamus Coleman and Romelu Lukaku responding in kind. Ross and Seamus both picked up yellow cards, Ross a tad fortunate not to see red if the truth be told. That said, the faux hard man Horrendouson was quickly back into the game with no seeming ill effect from the challenge.

Ronald Koeman sent on Dominic Calvert-Lewin for the tiring Enner Valencia who had again impressed with a solid, hard-working effort.

Mignolet made an easy save from an Ashley Williams header from a Barkley free kick ahead of Robles denying Wijnaldum. With less than ten minutes left in normal time, Klippity sent on Charlie Can for Lallana and Sturridge for Origi.

Everton were tiring and ‘they’ were doing their level best to overly influence the referee with Mane going down on at least three occasions drawing free kicks and incensing the home fans, particularly when Gana saw yellow for a foul on the diving Mane.

Joel flapped at a corner as the fourth official indicated eight additional minutes and the almost inevitable extra-time game-breaker arrived. Wijnaldum spread a ball out wide to their right flank where Sturridge was able to collect and work his way across the face of the box before sending in a weak shot that eluded the stretch of Robles only to come back off the post with Mane quickest to react and score into the empty net.

True to form, ‘de best fans in de werld’ displayed their despicable side throwing two flares onto the pitch with a third brandished in the crowd – what’s the betting there is no disciplinary action taken against them.

Seamus Coleman made a dramatic clearance to deny Firmino a second goal and that was that.

Final Score: 0-1.

This was not a bad performance by Everton.

For half an hour, we were much the better side albeit without troubling Mignolet in the visitor’s goal.

The loss of McCarthy at the break proved to be crucial as his energy and pressing had most definitely unsettled the FC Ar Yeer.

For the Blues, the telling issue was the missing key element of quality. Had we had that bit more composure and a more clinical finishing touch, and had we been able to sustain the effort of the first half hour for the full ninety minutes then who knows what might have been.

Nobody in blue was abjectly poor, everyone in blue worked hard – and the mental frailty we’ve been dogged by in previous years against ‘them’ was certainly not evident tonight. The bottom line is we just lacked that bit of quality needed to endorse solid, hard work… and we tired.

As for ‘them’ they are nowhere near as good as they think they are, but they always seem to get the breaks, and the collision that cost us Stekelenburg earned the additional time they needed to take advantage of our tiring limbs.
 

This was not a bad performance by Everton.

For half an hour, we were much the better side albeit without troubling Mignolet in the visitor’s goal.

The loss of McCarthy at the break proved to be crucial as his energy and pressing had most definitely unsettled the FC Ar Yeer.

For the Blues, the telling issue was the missing key element of quality. Had we had that bit more composure and a more clinical finishing touch, and had we been able to sustain the effort of the first half hour for the full ninety minutes then who knows what might have been.

Nobody in blue was abjectly poor, everyone in blue worked hard – and the mental frailty we’ve been dogged by in previous years against ‘them’ was certainly not evident tonight. The bottom line is we just lacked that bit of quality needed to endorse solid, hard work… and we tired.

As for ‘them’ they are nowhere near as good as they think they are, but they always seem to get the breaks, and the collision that cost us Stekelenburg earned the additional time they needed to take advantage of our tiring limbs.

Totally agree with your summary. Excellent report Andy as ever.

Many thanks
 

Thought we were the better side in the first 45, second half was more 50-50, but we just didn't have them chances or attempts on goal, trust the murds to be sh!t then get 8 minutes to sporn a shot that they score on the rebound ccccuuuùuu:rant::rant::rant::rant:
 
I am tempted to name Seamus but given the fact we fell to pieces after Jimmy Mac went off, my nomination hast to go to the latter.
 
Good report

Nobody in blue was abjectly poor, everyone in blue worked hard – and the mental frailty we’ve been dogged by in previous years against ‘them’ was certainly not evident tonight. The bottom line is we just lacked that bit of quality needed to endorse solid, hard work… and we tired.

I think the above is spot on.

It was a poor game, but surely everyone expected that and while I can understand the fume I've been reading on GOT, some of it is massively OTT.

Hopefully we can get a result at Leicester.
 

Coleman, Gana, Mori all played well. McCarthy as well. We were not the same thing team when he was replaced by Barry. The effort was there from most important of the lads, but the legs wore out (having to use a sub on a keeper hurt....).

Barkley was woeful and we have no end product. The offense, or rather lack thereof, must be addressed.
 
James going off (and I'm his biggest critic) was a turning point. Yes he can't make a forward pass but our midfield has looked much more solid with him and Gueye able to keep pace with the play. I'm afraid Barry is looking again, like his 2nd season, way passed the pace of the premiership.

It is crying out for Davies to be given a go with a BIG "if only" about Besic.

Barkley has proved countless times he is no number 10 and this season I'm starting to get on his back too. He was deplorable last night. When is the real Ross Barkley going to stand up? My feeling is when he is given the number 8 role, but no manager seems to trust him.

Im expecting Koeman to want to make some major changes come January, which will be a pity for Davies and Walsh...
 
....we missed McCarthy but the signs were already there in the last 15mins that it was attack v defence. I disagree slightly with Andy's summary, 'as for them they are nowhere near as good as they think they are but they always seem to get the breaks'. For an hour of that game there was only one team trying to win it, when you have that much possession in and around your opponents box you are going to get a break or two.

Also, whilst the back four, keepers and DMs generally managed to deal with the onslaught we were very poor going the other way. In the 2nd half our wide players and Barkley failed to provide the pressure relief by getting their full backs and DMs going back towards their goal. I thought one or two were bordering on abject.
 
Apologies for the delay, massively delayed in traffic on the way home...

Derby hoodoo strikes again.

Everton 0 - 1 Them

Brief Summary…A highly charged ‘derby’ went the way of the visitors as Everton ran out of gas and Sadio Mane pounced in the 94th minute to wreck Ronald Koeman’s home record..

Another evening game under the Grand Old Lady’s lights – how many more will there be for us to enjoy - and Blues fans keen to go into Christmas with smiles on our faces with victory over ‘them’ to enjoy along with the turkey, mince pies and the occasional tipple or three.

Ronald Koeman selected his first derby line-up: Stekelenburg, Baines, Williams, Funes Mori, Coleman, Gueye, Barkley, McCarthy, Lennon, Valencia and Lukaku.

Klippity lined ‘them’ up: Mignolet, Clyne, Lovren, Klavan, Milner, Henderson, Wijnaldum, Lallana, Firmino, Origi and Mane.

The Wirral’s’ Mike Dean was the referee under close scrutiny given his recent record of red card waving.

A passionate atmosphere saw a frenetic opening with Everton biting into the tackle and unsettling ‘them’ right from the off. A Coleman cross saw Lovren clear with a hurried header and the Blues were pressuring ‘them’ closing quickly and playing with great energy.

Valencia set Rom free down the right but his cross was too strong and went to safety. Everton wasted a free kick following a Firmino foul on Valencia and Lovren made a key block as Ross tried to release Rom through the left side.

Everton were much the better side through the first twenty minutes and a nice move involving Lennon and Barkley saw Klavan make a telling block to foil Lukaku while Klippity raged on the side-line

With half an hour gone and neither goalie tested in the slightest, Everton eased up and ‘they’ began to get a foothold into the game, but RFM outfought Orighi before another right wing move saw a cross from Coleman appear to hit the hand of Horrendouson only for referee Mike Dean to wave away half-hearted penalty claims.

They countered and arguably the best chance of the first half so far saw Orighi do his Mesut Ozil impersonation spooning a shot high and wide into the Street End.

The hard-working James McCarthy, who had had a fine first half hour, went down on 38 minutes and needed treatment for cramp. As the first half wound down, the Blues won the game’s first corner kick and the cross from Ross saw RFM find space for a free header that really should have hit the target.

Half Time: 0-0

Gareth Barry replaced Jimmy Mac for the second half and good as player as he is, Gaz Baz hasn’t the high energy game that McCarthy had employed to such good effect in tandem with the ever-industrious Gana Gueye.

The loss of McCarthy was seized upon by ‘them’ as they upped their effort and forced Aaron Lennon into a hurried and miscued clearance for their first corner.

Some rather hurried and desperate defending was needed when Firmino worked a left flank opening and Stekelenburg made an instinctive save but the ball went pin balling around the area before eventually being cleared to safety.

Gana broke up an attack to release Barkley through midfield where he was bundled off the ball by Firmino who avoided a yellow card. Barry sent a long chip over the top for Lukaku but his header cleared the crossbar.

Referee Mike Dean finally brandished yellow on 55 minutes as Lovren blatantly blocked Lukaku turning sweetly on a short ball from Barkley.

The next major incident saw Baines and Stekelenburg collide painfully for the goalie in denying Mane, with a long delay before play resumed, and that eventually saw him limp out of the game to be replaced by Joel Robles on 63 minutes.

Tempers came close to fraying a couple of minutes later as Barkley went in late on Horrendouson and Lovren raced twenty yards to stick his ugly oar in, Seamus Coleman and Romelu Lukaku responding in kind. Ross and Seamus both picked up yellow cards, Ross a tad fortunate not to see red if the truth be told. That said, the faux hard man Horrendouson was quickly back into the game with no seeming ill effect from the challenge.

Ronald Koeman sent on Dominic Calvert-Lewin for the tiring Enner Valencia who had again impressed with a solid, hard-working effort.

Mignolet made an easy save from an Ashley Williams header from a Barkley free kick ahead of Robles denying Wijnaldum. With less than ten minutes left in normal time, Klippity sent on Charlie Can for Lallana and Sturridge for Origi.

Everton were tiring and ‘they’ were doing their level best to overly influence the referee with Mane going down on at least three occasions drawing free kicks and incensing the home fans, particularly when Gana saw yellow for a foul on the diving Mane.

Joel flapped at a corner as the fourth official indicated eight additional minutes and the almost inevitable extra-time game-breaker arrived. Wijnaldum spread a ball out wide to their right flank where Sturridge was able to collect and work his way across the face of the box before sending in a weak shot that eluded the stretch of Robles only to come back off the post with Mane quickest to react and score into the empty net.

True to form, ‘de best fans in de werld’ displayed their despicable side throwing two flares onto the pitch with a third brandished in the crowd – what’s the betting there is no disciplinary action taken against them.

Seamus Coleman made a dramatic clearance to deny Firmino a second goal and that was that.

Final Score: 0-1.

This was not a bad performance by Everton.

For half an hour, we were much the better side albeit without troubling Mignolet in the visitor’s goal.

The loss of McCarthy at the break proved to be crucial as his energy and pressing had most definitely unsettled the FC Ar Yeer.

For the Blues, the telling issue was the missing key element of quality. Had we had that bit more composure and a more clinical finishing touch, and had we been able to sustain the effort of the first half hour for the full ninety minutes then who knows what might have been.

Nobody in blue was abjectly poor, everyone in blue worked hard – and the mental frailty we’ve been dogged by in previous years against ‘them’ was certainly not evident tonight. The bottom line is we just lacked that bit of quality needed to endorse solid, hard work… and we tired.

As for ‘them’ they are nowhere near as good as they think they are, but they always seem to get the breaks, and the collision that cost us Stekelenburg earned the additional time they needed to take advantage of our tiring limbs.
Good report. Agreed. And so it goes. Another derby where the football gods gave precedence to that lot. The crowd, as usual on these occasions, gave it their all, and in the first half, so did most of the players. Unfortunately, quality and talent was lacking in key areas, and so no advantage could be made of an opposition defence that looked at times confused and weak.
The red lot, despite all the biased pundit propaganda, were beatable, and yet there we were, in a post half time daze, watching them control the game on our turf. No surprise we would be put to the sword sometime during the vastly allotted injury time. It was written in the script, although I half expected an own goal, or penalty. What do I know?!
Relief, in a way, that now it is done, we can move on, work on righting the wrongs, strengthening the squad and getting the stadium nailed down.
Our time will come. Just hope I live long enough to see it!
 
Good report. Agreed. And so it goes. Another derby where the football gods gave precedence to that lot. The crowd, as usual on these occasions, gave it their all, and in the first half, so did most of the players. Unfortunately, quality and talent was lacking in key areas, and so no advantage could be made of an opposition defence that looked at times confused and weak.
The red lot, despite all the biased pundit propaganda, were beatable, and yet there we were, in a post half time daze, watching them control the game on our turf. No surprise we would be put to the sword sometime during the vastly allotted injury time. It was written in the script, although I half expected an own goal, or penalty. What do I know?!
Relief, in a way, that now it is done, we can move on, work on righting the wrongs, strengthening the squad and getting the stadium nailed down.
Our time will come. Just hope I live long enough to see it!


...whilst I dislike them as much as everybody and have a list as long as my arm of bad luck, bad refereeing decisions and injustice I think it's wrong to add last night to the list. When you are camped in and around your opponents box for an hour it's not 'football gods' that give you a break or two, especially when you offer absolutely nothing in the other half of the pitch.

The Reds were the only team wanting to win that game for the last 60 mins, even after they scored they could have scored again. Whilst it would have been great to hold on there was no luck about their victory.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top