Ernesto Che Guevara

Hero or Villain?

  • Hero

  • Villain

  • A fine maker of cheese on toast no doubt


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Azzurri

Player Valuation: £70m
Liberator? Oppressor? Murderer? Freedom fighter? Tell me...








By the way, it makes me laugh that thousands of (young) Americans who are scared senseless of anything even resembling communism wear his image. How he'd have hated that.
 

S9xUsz8.jpg
 
Hero I think, but certainly ruthless, signing the execution orders on leaders of the old regime in Cuba. Strangely, he had little interest in politics until well into his 20s, having been devoted to his medical studies before. He had an Irish maternal grandmother.

I've visited his mausoleum in Cuba, quite an experience.
 

A committed believer in his ideals, and prepared to die for what he believed in.
The following he enjoyed and the reverence in which he is still held is testament to those ideals if not some of his methodology.
Allegedly, his last words before being executed were, "shoot you coward, you are only killing a man." Meaning they could kill him, but not his ideals and the socialist movement in Cuba and elsewhere that he had nurtured, led and tried to take to other countries.
 
Definitely a hero in my opinion. Him and Castro both overthrew the Batista regime which was corrupt and in bed with the yanks. Both from well to do families and could have picked an easier route in life but both fought for what they believed in. Don't personally think socialism works to this extreme like but the people have health-care, education, accommodation and food.
 

A committed believer in his ideals, and prepared to die for what he believed in.
The following he enjoyed and the reverence in which he is still held is testament to those ideals if not some of his methodology.
Allegedly, his last words before being executed were, "shoot you coward, you are only killing a man." Meaning they could kill him, but not his ideals and the socialist movement in Cuba and elsewhere that he had nurtured, led and tried to take to other countries.

He tried to export revolution to the Congo and to Bolivia but with little success and without much support from Fidel who tried to talk him out of it and get him to stay in Cuba. Che even renounced his honorary Cuban citizenship before leaving for Congo in the mid-60s to show that he wanted international revolution beyond single countries.
 
He tried to export revolution to the Congo and to Bolivia but with little success and without much support from Fidel who tried to talk him out of it and get him to stay in Cuba. Che even renounced his honorary Cuban citizenship before leaving for Congo in the mid-60s to show that he wanted international revolution beyond single countries.

His Bolivian diary is an incredible read in my opinion. Despite the incredible odds against him and any chance of success, he and his hardy band of followers kept trying to encourage the local people to stand up against the capitalist system imposed by a U.S. backed government. It was a campaign doomed to failure right from the outset and the question remains whether Che ultimately sacrificed himself, maybe sub-consciously, to highlight the struggle.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top