• Participation within this 'World Football' is only available to members who have had 5+ posts approved elsewhere.

3pm Kick-offs. Should they be televised?

After the quotes by the fella from Virgin media, should they televise all Premiership games?

  • No, absolutely not.

  • No, but stop playing 3pm Saturday games in the Prem.

  • Yes, Absolutely, carte blanche.

  • Yes, with regional black-outs until stadiums are sold out.

  • Cheese on your remote at 15:05


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Jacko93

Player Valuation: £35m
Just wondering on people thoughts on this.

I understand the reasons for them not being televised up to now, which is why I've added a few caveats to the poll. Any other ideas for making it work/Why it wouldn't work


http://www.theguardian.com/football...dia-premier-league-live-broadcast-all-matches

Virgin Media calls on Premier League to allow live broadcast of all matches
• Tom Mockridge suggests regional blackouts could solve 3pm kick-off issue
• ‘Consumers are entitled to make their own choices,’ says Virgin chief executive


The Virgin Media chief executive, Tom Mockridge, would like the Premier League to consider regional TV blackouts to enable the showing of live 3pm kick-offs. Photograph: Peter Byrne/PA Wire


Owen Gibson


The head of Virgin Media, Tom Mockridge, has called on the Premier League to consider introducing US-style regional blackouts to enable it to show all 380 matches live on television.

The pay-TV company has also made it plain it does not expect the media regulator Ofcom to rip up the Premier League’s existing deals, expected to bring in more than £8.5bn, but that any changes should apply to the next contract, starting in the 2019-20 season.

Virgin has filed a complaint with the regulator arguing that by making only 41% of all matches available to broadcasters, the Premier League is keeping prices artificially high and restricting choice to consumers.

The Premier League, in unusual alignment with the Football Supporters’ Federation on the issue, argues that it is necessary to protect the 3pm blackout window on a Saturday to safeguard attendance in lower league football.

Advertisement
In other countries such as Germany, and with other leagues such as the NBA and the NFL in the US, it is common for fans to be able to watch all games or purchase a pass that allows them to follow their team.

Mockridge said the move was necessary to curb continuing inflation in the cost of live rights that was hurting consumers. He said 77% of Virgin customers, around a third of whom subscribe to BT Sport and Sky Sports, thought that sports channels were now too expensive.

Arguing the provisions had created a “nanny state”, Mockridge said: “Consumers are entitled to make their own choices rather than have other people make them for them.”

Under the three-year contract that begins next season, Sky and BT will pay £5.1bn – an 80% increase on the current deal.

Mockridge said making all matches available live may not bring the overall cost down but would act as a brake on inflation and allow fans more choice. He said the rules in the UK were an anachronism compared with the US and the rest of Europe.

“The Premier League argues there is a consumer benefit in limiting the number of matches. We would argue the opposite,” said Mockridge. “I am not criticising the Premier League. Richard Scudamore has done a terrific job for them but it’s up to Ofcom to act as the referee. Their primary aim is to protect the consumer. What is the consumer benefit in showing only 40% of the games on TV?”

Lower league clubs and their fans have traditionally lobbied against dropping the 3pm blackout for fear it would hit attendances. Mockridge suggested that, if they were given a greater proportion of the Premier League’s television money and protected by technology that would stop fans in Manchester watching Manchester United instead of Bury, they may feel differently.

Such a system works for the NFL in the US and, while Mockridge accepted there were cultural and geographical differences in the UK, he said the idea should be considered for those games that kick off at 3pm on a Saturday and are not shown on TV.

While it is unclear whether the idea would translate to the UK – where the unintended consequence may be that supporters of Manchester United could end up travelling to Liverpool to watch their side on television – Mockridge said the technology existed and was worth exploring.

The media regulator Ofcom has been looking into Virgin’s complaint for more than a year and is conducting a detailed review. There is no timescale for a decision but Ofcom has said the review could take up to two years in total.
 

would the answer not be to play NONE of the Premier League matches at 3pm on a Saturday. Thus allowing TV to show all of them and the lower league teams to have their 3pm Saturday game unhindered by supporters going off to watch 'big clubs'

Televise PL games from Friday night though to Monday night and everyone's a winner.
 

Think that would hurt attendance more.
who's attendance would it hurt?
PL Clubs aren't that bothered by attendances, their fluctuations aren't that big financially when compared to the rest of their income and it would level the field as ALL PL teams would receive the same amount of TV appearance money (which the big teams currently gobble up)

Lower League Supporters would still go in the same numbers, and probably increase their pull as supporters out for the day can still watch their 'big' team.
 
Playing no games at 3, I dunno as i'm a bit of a traditionalist. I love going the game when its a 3 o'clock kick off, beers in the pub from 12 till 2.45 wander along county rd and into the ground at 5 to 3, followed by back in the pub for a large session. Nirvana :):pint2::pint2::pint2:
 
who's attendance would it hurt?
PL Clubs aren't that bothered by attendances, their fluctuations aren't that big financially when compared to the rest of their income and it would level the field as ALL PL teams would receive the same amount of TV appearance money (which the big teams currently gobble up)

Lower League Supporters would still go in the same numbers, and probably increase their pull as supporters out for the day can still watch their 'big' team.
I think blanket wall-wall coverage all week would devalue the Saturday and lower league games. I could be wrong, its just my initial thoughts, but when lower leagues are struggling for attendance already, largely because the all-consuming PL is vacuuming up the support base, and you then shift the focus of football onto evening games during the week and show every game it will mean further pressure on the lower leagues.
PL attendance may well suffer also, certainly I can see season ticket sales falling. I'm in Bristol, and in theory I could get a season ticket, would love to in fact, if I could guarantee that I could attend most matches and build 20 odd weekends a season around that. But once TV has moved a load of those games around getting a season ticket starts to look untenable.
 

I'll say no they shouldn't it might even the money out for a couple of years then teams will start to negotiate their own contracts with tv ending up with the big clubs getting a bigger slice of pie
 
Ok, so maybe a slightly different question. How about if we allowed the broadcast of Saturday 3pm games, but EVERY PL game was played at Saturday 3pm?
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top