If we lose Sat. Should Moyes be sacked?

If Moyes fails to win on Saturday, should he be sacked?

  • Yes ,he is incapable of change

    Votes: 77 23.8%

  • No he'll course correct

    Votes: 171 52.9%

  • Undecided

    Votes: 59 18.3%

  • Cheese on toast

    Votes: 16 5.0%
  • Total voters
    323
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Binman said:
No.

Why would you do that. A mixture of carp squad, overhauled in the summer, to a point. Carp strikers, carp fullbacks.

Rome wasn’t built in a day friends.

I don’t think he will relegate us, he’s way better than the hoarse jockey we had previously, now at forest.

Not long term, sure, but to sack now?? Why??

And who would you have!?

A daft question at this point
Click to expand...
Why would you sack him? because he's not doing his job as a manager which is to win games. His tactics are predictable every week he's the one refuses to change at all especially with team selection or game management, you think it's daft to want to bring in someone actually versatile, I think it's asinine to continue with a stubborn relic who is unwilling to adapt. Also he was heavily involved in the recruitment process if we are lacking in certain positions it is on him. Our squad was worse last season and I thought he did a decent job. Another thing if he wins Saturday then I'll be happy it's just that when are expecting him resurrect things if he loses to an underwhelming Fulham side when we have won 1 game since August. West Ham had a nightmare season and they're only 5 points behind us.
 

Curtis said:
Why would you sack him? because he's not doing his job as a manager which is to win games. His tactics are predictable every week he's the one refuses to change at all especially with team selection or game management, you think it's daft to want to bring in someone actually versatile, I think it's asinine to continue with a stubborn relic who is unwilling to adapt. Also he was heavily involved in the recruitment process if we are lacking in certain positions it is on him. Our squad was worse last season and I thought he did a decent job. Another thing if he wins Saturday then I'll be happy it's just that when are expecting him resurrect things if he loses to an underwhelming Fulham side when we have won 1 game since August. West Ham had a nightmare season and they're only 5 points behind us.
Click to expand...
I didnt say anything about bringing anyone versatile, but you dont mention anyone, who is versatile, who may do a better job. I dont doubt he was involved in transfers. The three new ones who arent playing, 2 of them you may need to question why. But im sure they will get time, eventually.
I mean if it came to it, and they do sack him after fulham, there would be a sense of irony, given his very first game for us. This time we dont have a certain mr unsworth to step up.

The team is short in a number of areas still.
But i just dont think now is the time to sack, hes only been here 5 minutes. All managers make mistakes. Even the slot machine is getting it he won the league last year. Yes they are both limited, but we are where we are.

Time is needed at this point not knee jerk.
 
Not going to happen. There's nobody available who would be a proven upgrade so at best its a case of taking a gamble on the unknown. He's here till the end of the season at least when the owners can evaluate the job he's done and if they think it necessary, can find a suitable upgrade who will then have the benefit of not being dropped in the deep end mid-season.
 

No wonder we are known as bitter blues. Some of our fan base have no knowledge of our history and tradition.
We have had the best squad in my opinion for a long time. The only department we are lacking is up front. Beto scored goals last season and for some reason has failed to find the net this season. Barry was bought by Moyes and I’m sure once he gets a goal confidence will come.
Failing that, Moyes will find a striker in January. He’s not going to put his on job on the line.
The strikers are our main source for goals, but shouldn’t goals from come from other areas too?
Midfielders and defender ls need to contribute too.
Anyone thinking Moyes should go imo are deluded.
Rogers, Postecoglu, Pereira and Co, take your pick.
 
If we end the month where we are right now or worse in a season where Palace, Forest and Villa are playing PL/European games each week there's a decision to be made.

The players are there to play in a different way, and he has choices off the bench. There's no excuse for any manager of this club now to be where we are or to be there in three weeks time. This isn't the past few seasons where we're fighting a rearguard battle and scrapping for points. The quality is there.
 

Screenshot 2025-11-07 at 09.13.27.webp
 
alan ball said:
No wonder we are known as bitter blues. Some of our fan base have no knowledge of our history and tradition.
We have had the best squad in my opinion for a long time. The only department we are lacking is up front. Beto scored goals last season and for some reason has failed to find the net this season. Barry was bought by Moyes and I’m sure once he gets a goal confidence will come.
Failing that, Moyes will find a striker in January. He’s not going to put his on job on the line.
The strikers are our main source for goals, but shouldn’t goals from come from other areas too?
Midfielders and defender ls need to contribute too.
Anyone thinking Moyes should go imo are deluded.
Rogers, Postecoglu, Pereira and Co, take your pick.
Click to expand...
You’re correct. We do have the best squad we’ve had in a while and we’ve won one game since August, been knocked out of a cup by the worst team in the league and are hovering above the relegation zone. I wonder whose fault that might be.
 
It's interesting to realize some people on this forum are incapable of engaging in discourse when you just introduce questions about an reoccurring issue that doesn't seem to resolving itself. I've even said if he's able to pull off Saturday or even change his tactics I would be more supportive of him. I'm just growing weary of watching the same failed approach every week with no effort to alter the predicament. I'm trying to be civil in my conduct and I understand the opposing outlook presented by other posters (I'm trying to attack anyone), but instead I get condescending remarks like I don't know the history of this club...for having deviating stances
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top