Rate Everton's Transfer Window

[bicycleheader]

Why don’t you like the manager

I was pretty damn tired of him after 11 seasons, I’d like my fresh starts to be a bit more fresh!

But can’t knock the job he is doing

 

[Blue Neon]

We needed a marauding RB and we only have 2 strikers now.

Two "strikers" in name only. Not impressed with either to help get us get near Top 6 with goals.

 

[matty1878]

7 the fact we need a RB and have for sometime is pathetic still would love to hear the explanation behind it.

But we’re only going with TWO strikers
That could be risky


And everyone’s obsessed with this RB
Ffs

 

[SJB]

8/10. Mental that we didn't sigh a fit and competent right back and have no cover at LB for Myko but the signings we've made have improved us massively, we were a joy to watch at times against Wolves and Brighton.

 

[SpiritOfTheBloos]

Real solid 8 for me.

Have to take it into context some of the horrendous starting line ups we’ve had last season and years prior, compared to now.

But seriously solid window that’s made us fun to watch again, and the start of a long road out of misery, and away from some truly appalling footballers.

Points marked down for the obvious right back situation. And for the early faffing around of the right wing targets. Did well in the end to get dibbling for a reduced fee though so credit there.

Long term fixes still needing for me Right back, Striker, Gana understudy and a decent versatile winger. McNeil is one we good really do with upgrading on we are still a bit light on the wings all things considered.

 

[rochdaleblue]

We released a lot of players who were a drain on our wage bill who contributed nothing and also released players who contributed very little. I’m still worried about our full back cover. If we’d got Tete over the line early on - it would have made such a difference. Would have loved Ake to provide LB and CH cover. I’m greedy, but still think we’re a little short up front. Would have loved Muani on loan up front - before spurs got him late in the window. However to see the impact KDH and In particular Grealish have made is fantastic. Dibling is a talent and is definitely one for the future. I’d give it 8/10 overall.

 

[Rob17896]

8 for me. Staggered anyone would vote anything lower than a 7 tbh. Got tonnes done, one key disappointment is at RB (assuming Fort isn't a goer) but doesn't stop it being a very productive window - and it had to be.

Nine for me, we always want more but Grealish and KDH are worth nine between the two.

 

[DualityNSNO]

But we’re only going with TWO strikers
That could be risky


And everyone’s obsessed with this RB
Ffs

Well we also have 0 adequate right backs, maybe that's why people are obsessed

 

[DualityNSNO]

Anyway, Grealish and KDH are actual coups and bump this to an 8 for me.

Lacking depth in too many departments and hoping for no injuries is quite dumb imho but hope we stay lucky.

 

[bullybeef]

We are deffo stronger.

A RB and another ST would have produced a 9.5/10

 

[banno]

8 for me also. Quite happy....no very happy with our options of Grealish, KDH & Dibling. Transforms our attacking intent. Just a wee disappointed we never got a RB and another LB this window. Was never going to be a quick fix but positive signings nevertheless

 

[Howards tipple]

10 for me because we got rid of Neal Maupay and Mason Holgate.

Fair comment..forgot we got rid of that utter muppet

 

[mahermi1]

Solid 7/10 for me, big miss the obvious right back but not bad at all.

 

[leslad]

I went for a 6. bearing in mind the past few windows it's been in the 1-3 region.

very good getting in players with quality AND a point to prove in Hall and Grealish.

I feel like the other signings, whilst I'm happy we got bodies in and they are of a good age where they can improve, I think they are big gambles.

I also feel with Keane not suitable for a whole season, OBrien playing out of position, Tarkowski 33 years old and Branthwaite struggling for fitness, we've left ourselves short at the back.

that all said, I'm happier than previous years, hence the 6 and not the 3.

 

[Frosty1878]

But we’re only going with TWO strikers
That could be risky


And everyone’s obsessed with this RB
Ffs

Could be risky but Ndiaye if desperate could play there. We have TWO strikers we have 0 right backs that should be playing, our best RB is actually a 6’ 6” CB no wonder people are obsessed with a RB a position that’s been needed for near on 4/5 years now