Rate Everton's Transfer Window

[BlueStevie35]

7 for me, a right back would have made it higher

 

[nevsonlymate]

7 from me no right back again

5 for me no right back, cover for left back looks a long way off being ready, no defensive mid fielder and leaving us with 1 hit and miss striker and a newbie to the league is totally daft unless someone like Antonio is in the pipeline it’s all opinions gents

 

[Blue Neon]

Transfer rating - No decent full backs either side and certainly no decent main striker. One word - POOR. All the top teams have at least one main striker, we ain't got any! So a 5 rating.

 

[Paul Rideout]

7 for me, a right back would have made it higher

Same. A right back (even on loan) would have put it to a 9.

I cannot remember the last time we did better than a 3

 

[Nymzee]

7.5/10 for me.

Started the window with the left, finished on the right - assuming Rohl happens. Overall addressed a lot of areas but lack of right-back, defensive mid and probably a 3rd striker of a different profile dampens it for me. Also unsure why we just skipped 2 loan slots.

 

[roy vernon]

Disappointed not to get a right back in, once again, but, I've gone with an 8. I think we are much stronger than we were at the end of last season and we have added some real quality.

 

[Rich1878]

7 for me.

No Rb, a bit light in midfield also not much pace in the squad and could have done with a more proven striker at this level.

Rome wasn't built in a day, n all that. But definitely making progress, surely but steadily.

 

[NathDogg]

Helluva window imo, especially looking at the outgoings.

Solid 8 - a rb, cb and another forward option would have been 10/10

 

[Gazz]

I didn't expect any business today and would have rated it a solid 7.

I know nothing about Rohl but I'll bump it up to an 8 on principal.

Would have had full marks if we had a RB but it is what it is.

COYB!

 

[Bluelenny1984]

View attachment 323924
Helluva window imo, especially looking at the outgoings.

Solid 8 - a rb, cb and another forward option would have been 10/10

Them outgoing make my eyes bleed and actually show the impact the window has had in our team!

 

[Noble Savage]

If we got a decent right back in I’d vote a Lindsey Dawn Mackenzie , perfect 10 .
I will stick with a Linda Lusardi 8 .

 

[Jebus_lives]

I've gone 6. I've liked the transfer window. We've shifted out some dead wood and it feels like we've got a hungry younger entertaining team.

Bringing Grealish in has been great, KDH is a good signing.

I think we needed a CM who can stay calm and manage possession (Rohl may do that but he's only just signed).

Barry looks ok but I have a nagging feeling he's too much like Beto to offer us something different when we need it.

RW sorted which is a big tick.

I can't really believe we haven't signed a RB. It would've been my top priority all summer. We look thin in defence and I think this year is a real opportunity to push high up the league. It may bite us in the winter months.

 

[knowing your history]

Easily an 8/10 if not more. Infact will go for a 9 if Grealish becomes Team of the year contender as he's already threatening to be.

Sold no one major (always bemuses me why some posters always seem to think Branthwaite is about to go even when signing contract extensions). Signed a proven match winner in Grealish who has hit the ground running, good solid mid table player in Dewsbury-Hall who's a good fit and then three excellent young prospects. Aznou not quite ready yet and Barry and Dibling can be eased in from the bench gradually which is brilliant.

Considering the negativity at the start of July I'm very pleased. It is lightyears from just two years ago of Danjuma, Harrison, Ashley Young and Chermiti.

My only issue is the right hand side. I'd have liked a little more pace there and more of a solution at RB. Of course we know J O'B is solid there but ultimately there are only three other CBs and one is injured so relying on Tarks again being indestructible until safety is mathematically assured.

Also interested what the plan is just going with two CFs this season compared to three in previous years. Guessing Moyesie thinks Ndiaye could play at false 9 and that would bring Dibling in on the right?

Looking forward to seeing it all pan out. What is certain is there are far more goals across the forward line now compared to previous seasons so can continue winning games in the manner of Saturday against bottom half teams.

 

[Milkman]

I'm going to go with Zat's 3 out of 10 I think

 

[Milkman]

3 out of 10 Zats