Rate Everton's Transfer Window

[DanB90]

8

Happy to review in a few months when we’re calling them all bums.

 

[ToffeeScot]

8 for me so far. If we have managed to get a RB last minute then it would be a 9. A striker too and it's a 10.

 

[Tramps_mate]

7 from me.

I think that we actually needed LB cover more than RB!!

Plus a striker with Chermiti going!

 

[matty1878]

8 clear as day this window to prevs

 

[maccavennie]

6/10

Right back area once again neglected
Defensive mid area I'm worried about
Still haven't added enough pace
Very light up top

signing of Grealish has added an additional mark and moved it from 5/10 to 6/10.

 

[Thomasc]

I’ve gone 7 just because I think we are reliant on a fully fit back 4 all season.

 

[pfim]

8. RB was the big miss. But we got one of the most influential players on the market without a ridiculous current or future obligation. The majority of the signings were on the better side of youth.

 

[st.domingo]

7 for me on balance - which is still a good mark.

There have been some belters signed obvs, but the lack of attention to the well-known areas of need may well bite us on the bum in due course.

 

[Thomasc]

I scored 7 but was a Nathan Ake away from a 9

 

[Saint Domingo]

7 - a right back and reserve striker would have moved that score upwards.

Considering most of our recent windows have been about a 2 though it’s a positive step!

 

[Maxwell]

8.

Left it later than it should have been but considering the size of the task and the fact we've had no recruitment team all summer...very decent.

 

[Efcjake]

It's an 8 for me.

Grealish is a massive coup.

KDH has fit in well. Charly was a must at that price.

Some great youngsters in Dibling, Aznou, and Barry for reasonable prices.

Just missing that right back which I can't wrap my head around us not getting one in but overall you can't say it's not been improvements to both the first 11 and the squad profile/age.

 

[Shibbywiggles]

8/10
Very good signings
Didn’t re-sign DCL or Doucoure
Extended Branthwaite’s contract
Didn’t lose any good players
Big improvement on a team that performed very well last season under Moyes

Only reason it’s not higher than 8/10 is we don’t have better depth

 

[Eggs]

…..the new regime were left in a right mess with so many players out of contract. I think the renewals were pragmatic (Gueye, Keane) whilst not being held to ransom by others (DCL, Doucoure). Having strict understanding of a players worth is a good sign. Early acquisition of Alcaraz.

A few key signings I wasn’t overly keen on (Grealish, KDH) but Moyes explained he wanted greater quality in possession, particularly top third. He’s bringing in what we need, the signing of Grealish already looking a gem and raising our profile too.

Funny that our two big money signings (Barry and Dibling) were both on the bench at the weekend, but adding Rohl and Aznou is an indication of strategy of young players with real potential.

There was so much to do, unlikely it would happen in one window. We won’t truly know the worth until Christmas but I’d go a solid 8/10.

 

[matty1878]

the battle of good window vs others

has the good window voters

winning by a mile!