Why Everton’s dizzying new stadium is already a Mersey gem
Telegraph Sport gives its verdict on dazzling new home as club celebrate start of new era with victory over Brighton
Supporters enjoy the atmosphere inside Everton’s Hill Dickinson new home Credit: Getty Images/Michael Regan
Senior Sports Writer, at Hill Dickinson Stadium
24 August 2025 6:40pm BST
Over the road from Everton’s new home, supporters stood in the shade outside The Bramley Moore pub, gazing at the Hill Dickinson Stadium.
The Everton diaspora had made their pilgrimage from Kent, deep western Wales, Dublin and Hull, and that was just four random conversations on the walk from the city centre. Their faces were a mixture of admiration and wonder. The dominant mood was disbelief that all of this was now theirs.
It will take some time, a generation perhaps, for the route along the Mersey to rival that of Goodison Park via County Road. Rituals, neighbours, legroom and sightlines have all changed and it may be several seasons before this place has a true identity.
But it is never too early to pronounce judgment. As Everton celebrated a new era with
victory over Brighton, how did the country’s newest stadium fare on its first day of league football?
The beauty of the stadium is apparent as you come closer Credit: Getty Images/Michael Regan
The look
There has been plenty of uninformed carping about the removal of Unesco’s world heritage status from Liverpool and this stadium’s supposed role in the decision. Its ruling did mention the stadium, but only as a part of wider development of the former docks. Before the match there was a video seminar from architect Dan Meis, greeted on the pitch afterwards with an ovation fit for Barry Horne.
From a distance though, his creation could be anything. Conference hall, mega arena, Amazon distribution centre. As you come closer its beauty reveals itself, stately bricks at the bottom, curving steel above. It is striking and situated tastefully within its surroundings, with the site’s old cobbles and tramlines maintained. The Grade II listed hydraulic tower and Engine House have been restored, actual heritage rather than some contrived attempt to create it. Unesco has got a cheek.
Verdict: 8/10
Stadium architect Dan Meis was given an ovation by fans Credit: Getty Images/Clive Mason
The atmosphere
Building noise before kick-off was overwhelmed by the senselessly powerful speakers. Who knew the theme to
Z Cars had sub bass frequencies to rival a 90s night at Cream? Things quietened after the initial excitement faded, with Brighton fans asking “Is this the Emirates?” in the eighth minute.
With grumbles growing after a patchy start it was an ecstatic surprise when Iliman Ndiaye scored. The frenzy went up a notch when James Garner did the same but the reaction to Jordan Pickford’s penalty save might have eclipsed both goals. The sheer volume when the crowd reaches a peak is fearsome.
When it is quiet it is deathly, but you could say the same about Goodison. If you were EQing the fans like an audio engineer you might turn down the treble. The noise feels harsh at times, not quite the deep guttural roar of football’s past. Perhaps that is the point, sound you feel as much as hear.
Verdict: 8/10
The views
The much-trailed steepness of the stands is clear immediately and experienced in the quad muscles when climbing to the top rows. The gradient is 34.99° in many areas, with the legal limit 35°. Fingers crossed the quality assurance work is not referred to VAR.
Pushing to the extremes is worth it, the interior is quite unique for this country, agreeably square and and miraculously intimate for a 50k+ capacity. Crucially, despite many modern trappings, it feels like a football stadium, with flashy design secondary to the people filling the seats. Or the safe standing berths, as in the lower tier of the Dortmundesque south stand. If the match does not hold your attention there is also the vista of Bootle to admire from the windows above the north stand.
Verdict: 9/10
The steepness of the stands is clear immediately Credit: PA/Peter Byrne
Fan experience
Everton have benefited from the crimes committed at previous new-build stadiums, especially the disastrous dead zones around them. Here the “fan plaza” (their silly name) is airy and welcoming, just a shame that Gary Neville’s plan to buy a brick in Jamie Carragher’s name was thwarted by an attentive member of staff.
It was all very lovely in the last of the summer sun, it may be a different story in February. A delightful, or dangerous, innovation are the self-pour beer dispensers. Unfortunately these are sophisticated machines which will serve you exactly one pint for £6.95, this is not an unlimited refills situation like at a Pizza Hut buffet.
Some moans about queues for food, turnstiles and toilets from fans, with those in the club view level of seating in the east stand particularly affected. Empty seats were obvious everywhere in the minutes after half-time, suggesting all was not well on the concourses. These are surely teething issues which will be addressed in the coming months.
Verdict: 7/10
The stadium’s name has attracted jibes from some rival supporters Credit: Reuters/Peter Powell
The name
More unnecessary scorn about this from other supporters, who claim that the Hill Dickinson Stadium is in some way embarrassing. True it is plonked on the exterior in an overtly American touch, looking like a real-life map legend. But Hill Dickinson is no Dick’s Sporting Goods Park (Colorado), Crypto.com Arena (Los Angeles) or Kit Kat Crescent (York, briefly).
It is a 215-year old law firm with local roots. Nothing to be ashamed of in the current gambling-dominated climate. Bring on its affectionate shortening to ‘The Hilly Dick’.
Verdict: Get over it