2025/26 Charly Alcaraz

[SJB]

He played better than most tonight and Moyes told him he'd had a good game when he left the pitch. Sloppy mistake that led to the penalty, he'll learn from that.

 

[SuperKev91]

Not understanding the shouts for him being our best player. Ball bounced off him as many times as he trapped it.

Couple of nice touches and a decent give and go, sharp shot. He was awful with the ball tonight though. Goal was partly due to him losing the ball.

He looked out of his depth physically out there today.

 

[ToffeeTim]

I dont think he should start matches. Incredibly inconsistent. Even within the same game.

 

[Furey1878]

Don't want to be too harsh on the guy, mistakes happen. Was actually looking like himself once he was moved to the 10.

 

[Andy Gray Diving Headers]

Awful tonight. Couldn't stand up, too weak and turned backwards way too much. Worked hard but that's it.

 

[BigBeto1]

Wasn’t as bad as people are making out and when he got put in his proper position the whole team looked better. He was more involved than Ndiaye today

 

[Saint Domingo]

Too slow to ever be top class

 

[Abraders]

Wasn’t as bad as people are making out and when he got put in his proper position the whole team looked better. He was more involved than Ndiaye today

This, and whatever was going on with him slipping every two touches. Alcaraz is fine, the actual unit moving the ball forward is broken

 

[pfim]

Wasn’t as bad as people are making out and when he got put in his proper position the whole team looked better. He was more involved than Ndiaye today

Agreed. Can't slip there though, pass the ball and move forward.

 

[SuperKev91]

Too slow to ever be top class

And weak, for all his would be aggression he’s not actually that difficult to dispossess.

Doesn’t hide the ball well at all.

 

[Brownie]

Don't be the player that falls over. Wear the right boots. I thought he played alright overall but that is absolute Sunday League stuff.

 

[Efcjake]

He played better than most tonight and Moyes told him he'd had a good game when he left the pitch. Sloppy mistake that led to the penalty, he'll learn from that.

One of the worst offenders for giving the ball away today for me

 

[Zatara]

Can’t see how people don’t think he was our best player today.

Problem is he’s not really needed now that we have three others who could play 10 - and I’d swap him in a heartbeat for a right winger.

What 3 others can play 10?

Because if Moyes is playing Grealish on the left then Alcaraz is our best 10 by a mile.

The only player that put himself out there in the attack tonight and actually could have come off for him on a different night. Was the least worst of the bunch to me. Greal danced but didn't really do much (which is understandable as he was on the pitch late).

Cant believe Moyes continues to misuse him.

 

[FTY]

I thought he was our best attacker tbh even with the slip. Squad player level of ability if we wanna move up the table though

 

[jackyboy]

I don't think we should be playing him and Ndiaye in the same team.