I think you are overly generous as I am overly harsh.
The truth as always , lies somewhere in between .
Moyes is a good solid mid table PL manager .
He is generally good at keeping a team where its value suggests it should be .
He may occasionally breach that envelope of expectation by a small amount , mostly a few places upward occasionally downward .
But what he most definitely isn’t is inspired .
You get what it says on the tin , solid , dependable .
The difference in the football we played when Martinez took over his team was marked , the ‘School of Science ‘ banners in the St were celebrations of the return of enjoyment and pride in an Everton side that had palpably gone missing during most of Moyes long tenure.
As an observation , isn’t it odd how his teams habitually only play well for half a season ?
Guess we were lucky we got the ‘good half ‘ last season .