"Don't shoot Vinny!"It's the title,
I can't help it...
I’d have preferred going in another direction
But if he’s 4th choice CB on reasonable wages, I can accept it
But if he’s 4th choice CB on reasonable wages, I can accept it
That's one of Keano's best qualities tbf.
It's a sensible signing given how many other areas we need to focus and direct our transfer kitty on. I'm disappointed that he didn't choose to go somewhere he would play every week though.
McCall2Radzinski
Player Valuation: £950k
When i saw the confirmation of a new contract on my FB feed, I immediately thought of this forum.
Overreactions are our speciality. We don’t have time to waste this summer on searching for a 4th choice CB. It will take more than one transfer window to jettison all those we want to see rhe back of. In a year or two it will hopefully be Tarky occupying the 4th choice position as his career nears its end and we’ll have found another Jarred or Jake.
BainesontoastNEW
Player Valuation: £40m
Dependent on who we bring in at RB, I genuinely believe he'll get under 5 starts all season. I mean, even one of Tarkowski/JOB will be rotated. Moyes is a classical and doesn't historically rotate his CBs.
Who would you realistically want as 4th choice? A youngster from Brazil with no experience? 4th choice by nature generally is mediocre.
Harryflashman
Player Valuation: £60m
I think the point about how the reaction would have been had Dyche overseen this extension is also a very fair one .
NathDogg
Player Valuation: £50m
5 starts to many.
Answer - anyone but Keane, he’s been finished her for about 4 years.
What’s Keane experienced at?
Being awful, gifting goals to the opposition and cowardice in the tackle - I don’t want that at 50th choice cb, never mind 4th.
Give me a kid from anywhere, Bootle or Brazil, with no experience over that.
People were saying Jake O’Brien wasn’t experienced enough, in making excuses for Dyche not playing him, look how that turned out….
Like I said previously, if we can’t find better than Keane in the whole world of football, priority position or not, we are failing as a football club.
All fair points, He can be a liability.. He can also score goals. 4th choice I'm coming around to tbh. Good professional, will play when asked, you won't get drama when he's asked to play in different roles, I can see why Moyes thinks it's a no brainier. We need a squad and we need it filled.
BainesontoastNEW
Player Valuation: £40m
So you'd honestly rather put a youngster from the academy/Brazil in the firing line? Look at the pelters the likes of Kenny have got from sections of our support when the likes of Unsworth was playing the kids. Even Gordon was criticised and he's gone on to win a pot now. There’s just no winning sometimes I feel. JOB's treatment has been a rarity in my view. I'd hate to think how differently things would have gone for him had he made one mistake. Imagine all the "I told you so" conjecture?
I'm not a Keane advocate by any means, mate, but I just feel a dose of realism is needed. 4th choice CB is not historically a position to worry about, especially with no Europe. Look at the RS, they've just won the league, do you know who their 4th choice is? Joe bloody Gomez. I'm pretty sure Arsenal's is a Polish lad called Kiwior.
And yet you defended Patto to the hilt.
A below mediocrity fullback.
Or does he need " ANOTHER " chance under a new manager for us?
Welcome
Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.
Shop
