It genuinely is an outrage that Manchester City are yet again being given another transfer window to cement their future and reduce the severity of any kind of punishment they might receive for these charges.
They were allowed to cheat, allegedly, for over a decade, going from Premier League nobodies owned by a crooked Thai politician in 2008, to having the Abu Dhabi royal family take them over in 2009, immediately splash £32 million on Robinho--who didn't even know Manchester City existed--and then fake sponsorship deals which allowed them to spend over a billion and a half in the 15 years that have followed.
Their wealth has enabled them to not only escape punishment, but to future-proof any potential relegations or European bans by building a huge network of clubs they can take talent from ranging from clubs in South American, Spain, USA and Australia, to create a world class football academy that has soaked up all of the local talent, and to pay salaries far in excess of what their income should enable them to spend had they have acted according to the rules.
Let's look at some potential punishments...
- If they're kicked out of the Premier League, the Championship will no doubt (even if they're not obligated to) make room for them. They'd keep their entire squad and be challenging to win the Premier League again within two-three seasons.
- If they're given a multi-year transfer ban who cares? Their squad is enormous and they'd easily be qualifying for Champions League regardless.
- If they're fined hundreds of millions it does not matter one jot as the Abu Dhabi royal family make that money back in a day.
The only suitable punishment, in my opinion, would be expulsion from the Premier League and a ban from gaining promotion back to the Premier League for the duration that their cheating occurred and they stove off punishment via their own crooked legal threats - so about a decade and a half.
That way, although they would be able to qualify for the Europa League via winning a domestic cup, and the Champions League a season later if they could win the Europa League, the odds of them remaining a modern giant of a club would be massively reduced. Yes they'd win any league they ended up in, but they'd not be allowed back into the Premier League, their players would want to leave or stay and drain them of tens of millions a year under no obligation to leave, and they'd truly be punished for their wrongdoings.
I personally think even a 15-year ban from the Premier League is pretty light for what they've got away with, especially when you consider Everton were almost relegated simply for spending 20 million 'too much' on trying to build a stadium that would, in some small way, start to slowly bridge the gap between us and the new big clubs, including cheating Manchester City. Look at the silverware they've won via cheating - I think 25 years wouldn't be too big of a ban.
... but we all know they're getting away with it all.