Eh?, so because I don't rate him means I'd "barrack" him? grow up, Milner has been around for six years and I can't remember him doing anything, he's had 3 clubs already and is no better than what we have.
If he's all that why are Newcastle (who are utter rubbish) so willing to get shut?, Villa had him on loan and didn't make it permenant, buying Newcastle's cast offs will not take us forward.
I think he's bog average, the kind of player we should be looking at if we were 12/13th but not if we are "trying to catch the top 4", Milner will never be good enough for that.