The critics are comparing James' contribution to their utopian fantasy team that never happened. It's easy to dream of Everton buying young talented promising superstars and then compare James to that. What honest people should be doing is comparing James with the players that have actually...
That is just the official report. There were news, rumors and in interviews before anything official that made it clear James wanted to return to Madrid.
I get the feeling some people don't like James for personal reasons. The criticism doesn't make any sense. Everton is not a big team that can...
You can twist it the way you want it but it was James' decicion to leave. It doens't matter what Hoeness had previously said. If James wanted to stay Bayern would have bought him.
Oh man, you quickly lose your credibility if you say things that are not true. Bayern wanted to keep him, but James himself did not want to stay. In other words: James is good enough for Bayern.