Fernandes...

Status
Not open for further replies.
Welton Toffee said:
No, I said Sidwell would add more to the team. I have already said that Fernandes does have some incredible skill. More than Sidwell, sure. But Sidwell is a good player who I think would suit us perfectly.

This is my opinion, I am entitled to it, so don't just dismiss it with bloody smilies thanks.
Click to expand...

I respect your opinion mate. I'm just not convinced that opinions of a player are not tainted by what happened.

Just had the BK forum guy on City, and he said he was outstanding when he was at Everton. Moyes obviously saw something in him to warrant a bid for a permanent move. Be it in those sparks of genius, or how he was in training. Remember we only see 90 mins a week (usually).
 

Cal said:
How would he add more to the team?

So your saying Sidwell would add more to the team then Kaka?
Click to expand...

What?! No! Where the [Poor language removed] did I say that?!

I think Sidwell would add more to the team than FERNANDES. That is Manuel Fernandes, the player who we are rumoured to be interested in. Not Kaka.
 
Ghost hit on something there at the end of the day Welts has said it and I will say it IF Moyes signs Fernandes I will be behind him 100% As I have stated he will be a great player and I would rather see him play for us than against us.

Now heres a question-

Fernandes now or....
Appiah in the summer.
 

Welton Toffee said:
What?! No! Where the [Poor language removed] did I say that?!

I think Sidwell would add more to the team than FERNANDES. That is Manuel Fernandes, the player who we are rumoured to be interested in. Not Kaka.
Click to expand...

Why do you think Sidwell would add more to the team then Manny.
 
Cal said:
Why do you think Sidwell would add more to the team then Manny.
Click to expand...

Sidwell has proved he can play in the Premiership. Scores goals, creates chances. A 'Moyes' player, yes he works hard but he's a good player. I think he'd do well for us. As you all rightly say, Fernandes didn't have that much game time with us, therefore he is unproven in the Prem. From what I did see, I didn't think he was all that good.

I don't know what you want me to say tbh. I have given my opinions, I would prefer someone like Sidwell, but if Moyes signs Fernandes then I will be behind him 100% (how many more times do I have to say this?!) and hope he turns into a top quality player.
 

Welton Toffee said:
Sidwell has proved he can play in the Premiership. Scores goals, creates chances. A 'Moyes' player, yes he works hard but he's a good player. I think he'd do well for us. As you all rightly say, Fernandes didn't have that much game time with us, therefore he is unproven in the Prem. From what I did see, I didn't think he was all that good.

I don't know what you want me to say tbh. I have given my opinions, I would prefer someone like Sidwell, but if Moyes signs Fernandes then I will be behind him 100% (how many more times do I have to say this?!) and hope he turns into a top quality player.
Click to expand...

Manny is much better then Sidwell - much much much much better.

He has it all, can defend, not afraid to get stuck in, can pick a pass out, shoot, everything.

Sidwell is about Reading standard because he can look the big fish in a small pond.

Where if he went up a level, he'd only be average, he's worse then that at Chelsea.

He's absolutely [Poor language removed].
 
Cal said:
Manny is much better then Sidwell - much much much much better.

He has it all, can defend, not afraid to get stuck in, can pick a pass out, shoot, everything.

Sidwell is about Reading standard because he can look the big fish in a small pond.

Where if he went up a level, he'd only be average, he's worse then that at Chelsea.

He's absolutely [Poor language removed].
Click to expand...

Cal I find it hilarious how you can argue with the facts- we saw manyy play what 12 games max? Sidwell did it for over 5 seasons in English football. IN ENGLISH FOOTBALL. Manny is 20 and unproven, although I do think he will be a great player hes no way the finished article yet- ask Valencia.
 
Cal said:
Manny is much better then Sidwell - much much much much better.

He has it all, can defend, not afraid to get stuck in, can pick a pass out, shoot, everything.

Sidwell is about Reading standard because he can look the big fish in a small pond.

Where if he went up a level, he'd only be average, he's worse then that at Chelsea.

He's absolutely [Poor language removed].
Click to expand...

This is your opinion. And how is it, that I'm not allowed to judge Fernandes on his time at Everton because he never played enough. Yet Sidwell has played less than that for Chelsea and you can judge him as [Poor language removed]?

Look, I respect your opinion, I don't agree with it, but I respect it. I'd appreciate if you did the same.
 
Welton Toffee said:
This is your opinion. And how is it, that I'm not allowed to judge Fernandes on his time at Everton because he never played enough. Yet Sidwell has played less than that for Chelsea and you can judge him as [Poor language removed]?

Look, I respect your opinion, I don't agree with it, but I respect it. I'd appreciate if you did the same.
Click to expand...

Yes i take your opinion obviously, i know where your coming from.

But i just think if what happened in the summer with Manny didnt happen, your opinion would slightly change imo.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top