We've ruined the league again...
Jack Grealish transfer damages Premier League integrity and nobody seems to care
Opinion by Andy Dunn – 10:01, 16 Oct 2025
Crystal Palace’s smooth start to the season hit its first serious bump when Oliver Glasner’s side were beaten by Everton. That defeat allowed Manchester City to leapfrog Palace into fifth place, one point ahead.
City now face an Everton side buoyed by their late winner against Palace and the energy of their new stadium. But despite Everton’s decent form, their challenge at the Etihad is even tougher than usual—because David Moyes is barred from fielding his best team.
Specifically, Moyes cannot play Jack Grealish, the match-winner against Palace and arguably Everton’s standout performer this season. Premier League rules prevent loaned players from facing their parent clubs, meaning Grealish—on loan from Manchester City—must sit out.
This rule forces Everton to be weaker against City than they were against Palace, which raises serious questions about fairness. The Premier League facilitates a system where clubs can loan out top talent but shield themselves from facing it.
Pep Guardiola deemed Grealish surplus to requirements, yet won’t have to deal with him on the pitch. And while the rule applies to all clubs, not every team can borrow a £100 million player.
Grealish’s resurgence at Everton has been a joy to watch. He’s playing with freedom and enthusiasm, and fans across the country are enjoying it. But his exclusion from the City match highlights the flaws in the loan system.
Premier League clubs earn enough to buy players outright. Loan deals—especially involving marquee names—are often about convenience. Grealish needed minutes ahead of a World Cup; Everton needed a star to light up their new home.
Even if Grealish thrives at Everton, a permanent move seems unlikely. If a Champions League club comes calling, he’ll go. Just as Marcus Rashford’s productive loan at Aston Villa never looked like becoming permanent, Grealish’s spell is temporary.
For City, shedding part of Grealish’s wages for a year is a win. For Everton, it’s a boost. But for the integrity of the Premier League, it’s a loss.