VAR

[Kevsleftpeg]

VAR needs a serious, comprehensive review but the one thing they should put in place immediately as a result of this is that all replays for things like foul play should be at full speed only.

Slo-mo should only be used for determining objective fact, like whether the ball touches a hand.

There's not such things as objective fact when it comes to that lot. Exhibit number 1 the Rodri handball.

 

[Milk]

Personally, I found the cup games without VAR more like the old days with a few robust challenges allowed

It’s got silly. And if, as proposed, it’s going to be used for stuff such as corners then we may as well watch American football

 

[tonyhorne]

It’s got silly. And if, as proposed, it’s going to be used for stuff such as corners then we may as well watch American football

Or basketball. No contact allowed and take it in turns to pass it about a bit until someone works an opening for a shot. Athletic but (IMHO) a complete bore fest ...

 

[Toffeepot]

Watching Mid v Che in the comforting knowledge that VAR isn't going to ruin the game

 

[Jokerdan]

The English Football League system has been infiltrated by this American mindset of "EVERY play needs to be reviewed because we have to morally get every call correct". Well now you see the result of this American mindset. 20 years ago in America, we thought certain plays needed to be reviewed because you could see a live play should not have happened due to XYZ (pending sport): shot clock goes off in basketball before/after the ball was in the players hand, a 4th and 1 in American football and play happens with a ball being placed short of the first down maker, or a fan reaching over the wall in baseball to interfere an outfielder from catching a ball.

But where did this play review start?

In my opinion, this fever of plays NEEDING to be reviewed started on October 9, 1996 at Yankee Stadium in the Bronx, New York. Quoting the historical event from wikipedia just for summary purposes:

"During Game 1 of the 1996 American League Championship Series between the New York Yankees and the Baltimore Orioles, Maier deflected a batted ball, hit by Derek Jeter, into the Yankee Stadium stands for what umpires ruled to be a home run, rather than fan interference. His interference altered the course of Game 1,[1] as the resulting home run allowed the Yankees to tie the score.[2] They emerged victorious from the game and won the series four games to one en route to winning the World Series."

If yall watch the replay this kid, who was 12 at the time, literally stuck his glove over the wall and interfered with the outfielder.

"Jeffrey Maier (born November 15, 1983) is an American baseball fan who received media attention for an incident in which he was involved as a 12-year-old at a baseball game."

The national outcry at the time was WE NEED TO GET ALL THE CALLS CORRECT. So gradually we started seeing reviews in all sports. One of the more famous plays NOT REVIEWED was the 2002 College Football National Championship game between the University of Miami and Ohio State University =



THIS IS NOT PASS INTERFERENCE!!!!!!!!!!!! A simple review would have overturned that call and Miami would have (should have) won this game. But now we review every stupid pass interference in 2023/2024.

The catch by Dez Bryant of the Dallas Cowboys, another famous replay overturn WHICH WAS A CATCH:



The catch by Calvin Johnson of the Detroit Lions in 2010, a replay overturned this catch:



I have even sat through replays in meaningless college volleyball matches my wife takes me to in the San Diego area. You sit there watching one team beat the crap out of the other, but yet they want to review one play that is worthless to the outcome of the match. I am 35, born in 1988, so I have seen a lot of change in sports specifically in the last 25 years. Replays overturning good plays and replays not being used to overturn bad calls. This disease of "WE HAVE TO GET EVERYTHING RIGHT" has caused plenty of old dogs, like me, to because frustrated in watching sports. There are multiple reasons we, as sport viewers, do not like replays which are very obvious. However, at the end of the day this is an American mindset in my opinion. My brother-in-law is Irish. My sister and BIL reside in Dublin with their 3 kids. He is a Liverpool supporter. I have warned him for over a decade to resist ALL American mind sets in the game of football and daily life. All American business minded people care about is PROFITS AND MARGIN. So = AVOID AVOID AVOID especially in football. My advice = "Say NO to Drugs and Americans", except me I am cool.

Can't say I read it all...but I guess we are all singing off the same Hymn Sheet, Brother

 

[Johnniepk]

Watching Mid v Che in the comforting knowledge that VAR isn't going to ruin the game

Notice how the players just get up after a tackle or foul.

 

[PITA]

It didn't get given as a penalty VAR didn't think it was either and a lot of our own fans don't think it was a penalty so I think you might be exaggerating a bit. Like I said sometimes they get given sometimes they don't and that is why VAR doesn't help because two referees can look at the same incident and see it differently thats just how it is so VAR adds more confusion not less.

Out of interest, one or two of our fans also said that DCL deserved a red card. Just saying.

 

[arch stanton]

Out of interest, one or two of our fans also said that DCL deserved a red card. Just saying.

some of those fans needs a good sniffing from @davek's dog though

 

[Cameron Manning]

I have disliked the way VAR has been used since it’s inception and have said quite a few times that VAR will decide who is champions and who is relegated with its illogical use of the rules of the game, it is certainly driving plenty of fans at the game and TV viewers away from the game and it spoils the enjoyment of people at the game who have to wait for VAR‘s decision of a goal before they can finally applaud it.

 

[Toffeepot]

Notice how the players just get up after a tackle or foul.

Absolutely. The game flowed all round and I might be imagining it but even the ref seemed at ease and confident. No one looking over his shoulder ready to change his decisions perhaps
Dunno. Just prefer it without VAR, even though years ago I thought it would improve the game massively

 

[NilSatisOptimum]

Out of interest, one or two of our fans also said that DCL deserved a red card. Just saying.

Lose term is "fan" then...

 

[roy vernon]

I really think that this u turn over the Calvert Lewin red card is the beginning of the end for VAR. I truly hope so and good riddance to it if I am correct.

 

[mikel_88]

I really think that this u turn over the Calvert Lewin red card is the beginning of the end for VAR. I truly hope so and good riddance to it if I am correct.

Would like to hear why they wanted the red card but ofc we wont get that

 

[roy vernon]

Would like to hear why they wanted the red card but ofc we wont get that

We've got more chance of pishing on the sun than getting any degree of clarity over that.

 

[arch stanton]

VAR is a big bag of dog poo