Would you swap Vic for Doyle?????

[phooey77]

What i see in vic is a bit like collymore has all the talent to make it big but in his mind he does not believe it if we can tap into that we have some player

 

[jtl60]

Not a chance, when people moan about how ****e Victor is I really think they don't know how lucky they are that they never saw Brett Angell, Tommy Johnson, John Spencer etc, or if they did they have forgotten how bad these players were.

Doyle is on a par with Victor so I dont see the point

 

[daz4matty]

No.

Vic has scored 7 in his last 17 hasn't he? Give him stick but that is a good ratio and the lad is clearly improving. Doyle is a poor player.

Good shout vic could become a very good player

 

[sexualchocolate]

Not a chance, when people moan about how ****e Victor is I really think they don't know how lucky they are that they never saw Brett Angell, Tommy Johnson, John Spencer etc, or if they did they have forgotten how bad these players were.

Doyle is on a par with Victor so I dont see the point

the point being that Doyle is an outlet and can hold the ball up whereas Vic falls on his arse a lot - neither are going to bang in a sh1tload of goals

 

[noddy78]

In a word No. Doyle offers nothing big Vic doesn't.

 

[pfim]

Any rumor with a swap of players involved is just pure BS.

 

[Allezfan]

Honestly I'm not saying I rate Vic but he's suddenly looking half useful for the first time in years. Would be gutted to stick with the useless get for years of failiure and then dump him just as he comes good

 

[electricblue]

In a word No. Doyle offers nothing big Vic doesn't.

How about not going down like a sack of spuds at the slightest touch, and banging his fists at the ground in frustration ?
Celebrating scoring with his team mates instead of acting all huffy ?
Working much harder than him at chasing lost causes ?

It's a yes from me.

 

[Summerskin]

Good shout vic could become a very good player

We were saying that 6 years ago...

 

[LTblue]

Doyle is not as talented as Anichebe and 5 years older so no.

 

[NewRadical]

No I wouldn't.

Anichebe has had plenty of criticism in the past - and much of it deserved. But in 2012 he has been much improved, never going to be a world beater, but can do a job for us. Offers us more than Doyle could.

After I got home from last night's match with Leyton Orient I had a look through the match thread were I found plenty of criticism of Anichebe's performance - from people who had listened to the game on the radio! Trust me he had a decent game, and never stopped working.

 

[Zaschrona]

For Kevin Doyle? No. For Jamie O'Hara? Yes please!

 

[Allezfan]

After I got home from last night's match with Leyton Orient I had a look through the match thread were I found plenty of criticism of Anichebe's performance - from people who had listened to the game on the radio! Trust me he had a decent game, and never stopped working.

I was sitting next to a bloke who was convinced Anichebe had scored a hat trick until we talked him out of it. Despite the fact they announced the scorers by name he was positive that it was him who had scored the fifth goal and even more bizarely the first.

 

[RFUS]

No.

Vic is an average player with years in the tank.

Doyle is just an average player.

 

[toffeestillidie]

vic is a roll player, we can sub him on late to bully defenders or hold up the ball if we're winning,

doyle is just average