Top 3 best & worst value for money signings

[Big Sams Undies]

Loads to choose from for both best and worst. Thankfully I'm not old enough to remember the dark days of the 90s and early 00s so mine are mainly from about 2003 onwards.

Honourable mentions for Martyn, Carsley, Barry, Baines for best and Niasse, Williams, Kone for worst

Best:
Cahill
Arteta
Coleman

Worst:
Siggy
Klaassen
Kroldrup

 

[Bruce Wayne]

Loads to choose from for both best and worst. Thankfully I'm not old enough to remember the dark days of the 90s and early 00s so mine are mainly from about 2003 onwards.

Honourable mentions for Martyn, Carsley, Barry, Baines for best and Niasse, Williams, Kone for worst

Best:
Cahill
Arteta
Coleman

Worst:
Siggy
Klaassen
Kroldrup

Sandro would be the worst for me, as with his wages, he will have cost us the best part of £20 million and we got a handful of games and 1 goal from him.

 

[Alanbileysfeathercut]

Try these.
Mick ferguson
Mickey Walsh.
Williams.

Best .
Big Nev, ,Seamus I would say Cahill but Andy Gray the belief that changed the 80s.

 

[Tel001]

Since the prem ?

best
Martyn
Arteta
Cahill

worst
Bolasie
Sandro
Morgan

as of right now gbamin would be there but he hasn’t played so it’s harsh , but from a business point of view he’s actually given us less mins than Sandro

 

[blue61]

Best.
Peter Reid, got him for £60,000 a couple of years after he was valued at £600,000.
Tim Cahill, an absolute bargain
Neville Southall £150,000 say no more.
Worst
Nyarko for attitude
Siggurdson for value for money
James Beattie for being vastly overhyped

 

[john jako]

Since the prem ?

best
Martyn
Arteta
Cahill

worst
Bolasie
Sandro
Morgan

as of right now gbamin would be there but he hasn’t played so it’s harsh , but from a business point of view he’s actually given us less mins than Sandro

Agree about Gbamin. He cost us a fortune in transfer fees, wages, private doctors and antibiotics. Very unfortunate but the return on investment has been laughable.

 

[GwladysBlue]

Best:

Arteta
Cahill
Lescott

Worst:

Iwobi
Delph
Gbamin

 

[Neiler]

Lee Carsely was super value.
Seamus Coleman.
Leighton Baines for longevity
Kevin Campbell for what he gave us that year.

 

[The binman chronicles]

Kroldrup? He was only bought for 5 million, sold for 3 million and wages probably weren't all that in 2005. Compared to a lot of the signings of the last 7 or so years that could be put up as a beacon of how to do business.

 

[brieverton]

Best:
Coleman
Cahill
Campbell

Worst:
Sigurdsson
Bolasie
Sandro Ramirez

 

[MikeH72]

Sigurdsson is probably the worst value for money signing in English football history.

 

[Jim Hopper]

Ghana was a steal for £7m in this day and age.

 

[Connor]

Best:

Coleman
Cahill
Baines

Worst:

Sigurdsson
Sigurdsson
Sigurdsson

 

[Jim Hopper]

Jagielka, £4million. 12 years of great service. That David Moyes knew a bargain to be fair.

 

[Baines' left foot]

Lescott is one of the best. Cost £5m and we sold him on for £22m.