The summer 2013 Everton transfer rumourZ thread

[ANDYEFC95]

Mcgeadys got 5star skill moves on fifa

 

[ijjysmith]

Who's that then?

Loads of people.

Nacer Chadli for example.

Look mate, you can try and get to me all you want, i'm not the one who said Aiden McGeady wasn't the worst option, when he really very really nearly is.

 

[Petit]

Funny.

Obviously the best realistic option.

I'd venture that all Evertonians want the club to sign the best realistic option.

 

[ijjysmith]

I'd venture that all Evertonians want the club to sign the best realistic option.

You'd like to think so wouldn't you Emmanuel mate.

 

[tim cahill]

Apart from pace what are these lots of qualities then??

Ability to beat his man.

 

[Christiffa25]

Aiden mcGeady
285 apps for Celtic (who dominate there league along with rangers) and spartac Moscow (again good team in poor league)
43 goals.

Steven Naismith
291 apps for kilmarnock rangers and Everton
72 goals.

Better option than Naismith..... You sure??

 

[tim cahill]

Loads of people.

Nacer Chadli for example.

Look mate, you can try and get to me all you want, i'm not the one who said Aiden McGeady wasn't the worst option, when he really very really nearly is.

Trying to get to you?? Am I?

I was just asking for your opinion.

We don't really know what our budget would be for a winger which i my point, we don't know what is realistic or not. If £4 million was our budget then I think he'd be a decent option.

 

[tim cahill]

Aiden mcGeady
285 apps for Celtic (who dominate there league along with rangers) and spartac Moscow (again good team in poor league)
43 goals.

Steven Naismith
291 apps for kilmarnock rangers and Everton
72 goals.

Better option than Naismith..... You sure??

Naismith isn't a winger though is he???

 

[Christiffa25]

Ability to beat his man.

Occasionally an then do nothing with it!!

 

[The Hibbert Agenda]

Naismith isn't a winger though is he???

NO! BEHIND STRIKER! BUSTED KNEE! MARTINEZ OUT!

 

[LTblue]

The few times I have watched him, McGeady has looked bog standard and certainly not the standard of a top 6 PL club. I would actually rather sign Maloney.

 

[Christiffa25]

Naismith isn't a winger though is he???

Well yes actually. Maybe if you define his strongest posistion you could say off a striker but he's played plenty of football off the wings, especially the left. Bit of a myth the Naismith out of position shouts.

There both poor British players tbh who have done quite well in poor leagues in the best teams.

 

[tim cahill]

Occasionally an then do nothing with it!!

So who do you think would be a better option for under £4m?

 

[LTblue]

I would actually rather sign nobody than sign McGeady.

 

[tim cahill]

Well yes actually. Maybe if you define his strongest posistion you could say off a striker but he's played plenty of football off the wings, especially the left. Bit of a myth the Naismith out of position shouts.

There both poor British players tbh who have done quite well in poor leagues in the best teams.

Just because a player has played in a position before doesn't it that their position though. Would you class Demba Ba as a winger because he's played plenty of football there for Newcastle?